Recently reviewed a paper, and the editor made the decision to reject it the day after providing feedback. It seems that the initial review process is not very strict, as long as the topic is relevant and the formatting is correct, there is a high probability of it being sent for review.

(0) Thank | yichen2024

3.28 under review
3.31 still under review but the date has changed, it seems that another reviewer has accepted
Please, I hope the reviewers and editors will be merciful and give me a chance QAQ

(0) Thank | hhhzzz

3.26 Editor Assigned.

(0) Thank | 冲鸭鸭

3.24 is still a NEW submission.

(0) Thank | 冲鸭鸭

Just returned from revision, from Zone 3 to Zone 4. How can a journal that only publishes 101 articles a year still drop in ranking? It's really unreasonable.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

One day ago it was still three zones, but after waking up and checking the record, it has become four zones.

(0) Thank | 冲鸭鸭

3.18 新提交
3.20 编辑分配
Go for it!

(0) Thank | panpasicaoyuan

Together with the original poster, we are both documenting the 3.18 submission, but it appears that the manuscript number for 2025 is already approaching 900.

(0) Thank | 冲鸭鸭

Record the submission experience
Submitted on 2.23.2025
Reviewers Assigned on 3.10.2025 (changed editors in between)
As of 3.16.2025, the status is still Reviewers Assigned, but the date changed to 3.16, possibly due to the original external reviewer declining and a new review invitation being sent out
Currently on 3.18.2025, the status remains unchanged, wish me luck!

(0) Thank | hhhzzz

The external audit has been going on for over two months, feeling anxious.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

Do you know how long the external audit has been going on? It has been two months and there has been no progress.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

May I ask what is your current status now? How is the external audit going?

(0) Thank | ldaaa

May I ask what is the status of your external audit?

(0) Thank | ldaaa

May I ask, what is the status of the external audit?

(0) Thank | ldaaa

Can anyone share a detailed timeline? Thank you.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

Does "Editor invited" mean that the review process has started? Does anyone have a detailed submission process to share?

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

On August 12th, there has been no progress since the editor was assigned. How long will it take for the next steps to be taken?

(0) Thank | 一只撒野的病猫

Does anyone know what the technical review result "check the title in the title page of the manuscript" means? I don't understand.

(0) Thank | qingboli6688

OP, is your manuscript in the "with editor" status or "under review" status?

(0) Thank | DY214

My assigned editor has been waiting for a long time. What is the review process like for the OP?

(0) Thank | DY214

Hello, is the external review assigned by the editor?

(0) Thank | DY214

1. Around 10 days after submitting the manuscript, it will show "sent for external review".
2. It takes about 2 months to receive the external review feedback after entering the external review process.
3. The major revisions suggested in the external review feedback allowed for 2 months of revision time. After solidly revising for a little over a month, the manuscript was resubmitted.
4. Approximately 20 days after resubmission, the final decision was made, and the manuscript was accepted by the journal.
5. There are no Article Processing Charges (APC) for the journal. The entire process from submission to acceptance took 5 months, and although the waiting process was quite painful, the final result was perfect. Personally, I believe that the journal has high standards for article quality, and the research needs to be thorough and well-structured.

(1) Thank | luoxianjin

7.2 submission
7.22 new submission

Tired...

(0) Thank | Jie Yang

5.21 Editor Assigned

(0) Thank | SummerBlue

Is there anyone who has submitted their research recently? Could you please share your timeline?

(0) Thank | SummerBlue