My advisor suggested that I submit to this journal… after four separate submissions, one of my papers is finally accepted. Needless to say, not easy.

(1) Thank | Yasman

Already accepted. Received the fulfillment of a wish today.

(0) Thank | 骨科博士

I applied in August 2023; the first response came in January 2024. After submitting the repairs, I waited until January 2025. I submitted on January 27th and passed the technical test on January 30th. I got hired today. It's too slow!

(0) Thank | 骨科博士

The speed is extremely slow, as evidenced by the fact. After more than a year of review and 2 revisions, it was ultimately rejected! The final comment was that my idea was not novel enough, comparing it to recently published articles. This is ridiculous! My idea was from over a year ago! They took so long to review, surely there are better ideas now! I'm done with them! I dare not submit again, it's too much of a hassle.

(0) Thank | zjc850126

The reviewers of the magazine are quite responsible, and their questions are very detailed. After two major revisions and two minor revisions, the paper was finally accepted for publication.

(0) Thank | nini0054

The magazine review process is too slow. Since September, I have been looking for reviewers and have not received any feedback yet. The editor just sends official replies via email. But I only have a few months left before the deadline. The magazine is really slow.

(0) Thank | 是你的桃子啊

Both the editors and reviewers are very responsible. They must accurately address all issues and make revisions to the article according to feedback. However, the review process does take a long time.

(0) Thank | nini0054

If you're not in a hurry, you can give it a try, but the magazine review process is extremely slow.

(0) Thank | nini0054

The speed is terribly slow. Please refer to the image for evidence. Even after urging, there is no progress. The replies are also just official templates. The issue has been closed.

(0) Thank | zjc850126

Submission received
Submission status Date
Submission received
03 Jul 2024
Technical check
Submission status Date
Submission is under technical check
03 Jul 2024
Amendment requested
10 Jul 2024
Amendment received
10 Jul 2024
Amendment requested
15 Jul 2024
Amendment received
15 Jul 2024
Submission passed technical check
18 Jul 2024
Editorial assignment
Submission status Date
Ready for editorial assignment
18 Jul 2024
With editor
Submission status Date
Editor assigned
18 Jul 2024
Peer review
Submission status Date
First reviewer(s) invited
22 Aug 2024

(0) Thank | 晨风雅辰

I have not heard any news about my major repair for 8 months.

(0) Thank | zjc850126

The speed is very slow, it has been 8 months since the major repair and there is still no news.

(0) Thank | zjc850126

Review speed: 12.0 Experience sharing: With a major revision taking a year, is there a high chance of rejection for this journal if we follow the experts' advice for modifications?

(0) Thank | 岭南熙然

What step are we at now?

(0) Thank | Boyd Irving

How far have we come?

(0) Thank | 岭南东明

Editor assigned
18 Jul 2024

(0) Thank | 晨风雅辰

Pretty fast, the first review provided feedback after three months, and after one month of revisions, it was accepted directly. The only downside is that the response to emails from the editor is slow.

(0) Thank | thm

Review Speed: 6.0 | Submission Success Rate: 50.0
Experience Sharing: 2024.7.3
Technical check

(0) Thank | 晨风雅辰

It took 11 months and required 3 revisions

(0) Thank | haoran45

It's still very slow. The resubmission was on February 26th, and now it's already May 21st. There has been no progress at all. Students who are eager to publish should be careful to avoid this journal!

(0) Thank | 骨科博士

Is it possible to retract the submission directly if the editor has not responded to the withdrawal request email?

(0) Thank | thm

Submitted in April 2023, but still no first round result. Sent numerous inquiries in between, but no response. Unfortunately, had to withdraw the submission today. The journal is very slow, this submission will have to be a lesson learned

(0) Thank | lky2024

I am currently waiting for the result of an article I submitted on October 23 last year. It was revised on February 9, and the revised results were submitted on February 26. I am still waiting for the final decision. This journal is very slow!

(1) Thank | 骨科博士

21 Feb 2024 Submission received
29 Feb 2024 Submission passed technical check with some delay due to additional materials submitted
29 Feb 2024 Submission under peer review

(0) Thank | 祝各位早日满足毕业要求

Brother, I withdrew my submission. Considering that it has been ten months and I still haven't received any feedback on the first review, and I would need to make several revisions, I decided to withdraw my submission. This magazine is trash, wasting my time

(0) Thank | 黄土爱欣