The review speed was really slow, and it’s not easy to find reviewers for this journal. But they were serious and responsible, rejecting the manuscripts directly that didn’t meet the requirements. It's still a good journal.

(0) Thank | akasnail

Let me give feedback on the result: After the manuscript had been under review for 10 months, I was told that they're sorry that they didn't find a reviewer, so they rejected it and  hope that we could submit to the journal next time. That’s ridiculous!

(0) Thank | 被逼无奈搞科研

Regardless of the revision comments, the situation of each manuscript is different. The speed of BMC HSR is too slow. If you are anxious to publish, please consider carefully.

(1) Thank | taoran

Does anyone know how many reviewers' opinions are needed specifically, 2 or 3? If it's 3, it will take too long.

(0) Thank | 陈橙

Finding editors and reviewers was relatively quick, and the assigned editors and reviewers were quite efficient. Feedback was received within the first month of submission, and two rounds of revisions were carried out, one major and one minor. The major revision took some time, so the entire process from submission to acceptance took about 4 months

(0) Thank | 唐寒轻

Too slow, proceed with caution

(0) Thank | ooosehun

Finding reviewers is quite fast.

(0) Thank | sunmengya

Review speed: 12.0 | Submission success rate: 50.0
Experience sharing: It's really slow. There was no progress for six months after submission, then three rounds of revisions took over a month each. The whole process took about a year, so be cautious if you are in a hurry to graduate

(0) Thank | 水桥妍丽

Too slow

(0) Thank | 五虎乐青

Invested in August last year, received in February this year, quite slow

(0) Thank | 无冬素梅

The speed is too slow

(0) Thank | 无冬素梅

Patience, it took me over 2 months to receive feedback from my peers

(0) Thank | 是你的茂勋呀

I submitted an article and it has been in the "reviewers invited" status for over a month now with no progress. What should I do?

(0) Thank | 岳家彦灵

Review Speed: 6.0 | Submission Success Rate: 50.0
Experience Sharing: It took a year from submission to rejection, because it was rejected due to lack of informed consent. To be honest, I hope he rejected it sooner

(0) Thank | 小野寺承载

It has been 6 months since submission, with 1 reminder sent, but still no news

(0) Thank | 小野寺承载

How long does it usually take for the initial review? I also want to submit to this magazine, but I'm afraid it will take too long and I won't be able to get published before I graduate

(0) Thank | 蓉沼雯华

Discounts are available, I personally submit contributions without any financial support, and my salary is relatively low. So I was exempted directly

(0) Thank | 风陵慧雅

Very bad experience, six months and can not find reviewers!!!! Worst submission experience I had ever have. I will never deal with this journal or this publisher again. Agonizing. I finally withdraw the paper.

(0) Thank | stethoscope.med@gmail.com

Which journal did the original poster end up submitting to?

(0) Thank | 江南若华

Review Speed: 12.0 | Submission Hit Rate: 75.0 | Page Fees: 1390.0
Research Focus: Neurology
Experience sharing: It took one year from submission to acceptance

(0) Thank | 凌霄志诚

This year, it has increased to 17,000

(0) Thank | 桃花元春

Under review for 10 months, and then they told me, sorry, couldn't find a reviewer, rejected. Hope to submit to their journal again next time, haha

(0) Thank | 黛比霍伊尔

Review speed: 7.0 Experience sharing: Regret not listening to the advice from the upstairs. It has been 7 months since submission for review, plus the pre-review process, it feels like giving birth to a child

(0) Thank | 如冬公子

Regardless of the revision, each manuscript situation is different. The speed of BMC HSR is really slow. If you are in a hurry to publish, please consider carefully

(0) Thank | 行云永龙

Feeling is a relatively good journal, and there are not many reviewers, and Xiao Xiu accepted it.

(0) Thank | Chloe