May I ask, what does it mean to be "under consideration" all this time? Does it mean my submission will be rejected?

(0) Thank | Moods

2025.3.26 Under Review.

(0) Thank | wzj001

Seeing that others are very quick, I submitted my paper too slowly. It was under review as soon as it was submitted, and after 3 months, I sent two emails inquiring about the status, but received no response. Eventually, it was rejected without any reason given. The official response was: "After careful evaluation, we have decided not to consider publishing your manuscript in the Journal of Management and Decision Economics." Couldn't they have rejected it earlier if it was not suitable? It's just a waste of time.

(0) Thank | QAAQ

I submitted my manuscript in mid-October, but I haven't heard anything back yet.

(0) Thank | 乎其

Have you received any news about your paper?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

Have you received any news about your thesis?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

I applied in November last year and it is still under review. Do you know how long the first review process usually takes? Thank you.

(0) Thank | hjk_l00@00

Submitted in early December, but for no reason at all, it was rejected. I'm so frustrated!

(0) Thank | 论文一定发表成功

The submission made at the end of December was just rejected today. There are too many submissions, so the response time has become very long, and there were no reasons given for the rejection.

(0) Thank | agagagg

So far, there have been no results, waiting anxiously.

(0) Thank | 大熊的号

I invested at the end of last December, and it's still under review. I can't see the progress in the current Wiley system. It's frustrating. Please reply if you have any updates.

(0) Thank | agagagg

How long does it usually take for submissions to be reviewed for the first time?

(0) Thank | 大熊的号

How long does it usually take for the external review process to proceed? I submitted my manuscript on January 14th and it showed "Under Review" on the same day. However, the status has not changed since then, and it's almost been a month now. I'm not sure at which stage the manuscript is currently. The journal's website states that the average time from submission to the first decision is 10 days...

(0) Thank | 大熊的号

Great, congratulations! My submission was rejected, they said the journal does not accept content related to government economics. Did the journal actually review my article, or did they not provide any specific areas for revision?

(0) Thank | 菜菜猫1

The process was very fast, submitted on the 9th and accepted on the 17th. There were 3 minor revisions in between and one major revision, but it was accepted directly without any fees.

(0) Thank | jetzeten

UR has been changed to uppercase for four months. It should be submitted for external review in about half a month, but the system has not changed. The process will be much faster after UR is changed to uppercase.

(0) Thank | 小幸运

Could you please tell me how long it will take for the paper to be officially published after acceptance?

(0) Thank | kwokcheung

Submitted for rejection for more than fifty days, reason for rejection: unable to find reviewers.

(0) Thank | double-y

Have you made any progress, OPs?

(0) Thank | Chen a

Still no movement or sound...speechless.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

Reply to Hui: Yes, it's strange. I don't know why. Could it be because they have too many submissions? I noticed that the submission IDs are not the usual MDE-24XXX, and this journal has been really slow lately. It's been a month since the initial review and there has been no news at all.

(0) Thank | sigma1

Reply to sigma1: I have sent an email to the editorial department reflecting this issue, but the assistant editor only replied with the current status of my manuscript and did not provide a solution. The ScholarOne system is currently unable to accept submissions, and any submissions will be redirected to the Wiley system. Therefore, the only option is to wait for feedback from the editorial department. The information displayed on Wiley is highly delayed and of little value.

(0) Thank | 乎其

Response to Hu: I am the same, and if the number is not starting with MDE-XXXX, it is just a string of numbers. It can only be seen in the Wiley system, not in the ScholarOne system. I emailed the editorial department and they confirmed that the submission was successful.

(0) Thank | sigma1

Hi, I submitted directly on ScholarOne. After submitting, I could quickly see your status, with both an ID and a title.

(0) Thank | 看我眼色行事

Hello, I submitted my paper directly through the Wiley system. After submission, the editorial department sent an email saying that usually within one working day, I would receive further emails including additional instructions and the manuscript ID. However, I did not receive any follow-up emails, so I registered with ScholarOne using the same email as my Wiley account. However, after logging into the system, I did not see any information about my submission. Currently, I can only see that the status of my manuscript in the Wiley system is still "UR". I am not sure what your experience was like, and if you know how to check the status of a submission in ScholarOne. Thank you.

(0) Thank | 乎其