How many days have you all been rejected or under review (by 2025)?

(0) Thank | miss33

Can you please update me on the situation? It's been over ten days since I submitted my manuscript and it's still with the editor... Hopefully everything goes well.

(0) Thank | xiaopingari

May I ask if it has been reviewed? I also submitted it in early May, almost 20 days ago.

(0) Thank | suhanin

2025.1.12 Submitted to journal
2025.1.15 Under review
2025.2.25 Review complete: Major revision
2025.3.13 Submitted revised manuscript
2025.4.15 Review complete -- minor revision
2025.4.19 Submitted revised manuscript
2025.5.18 Review complete
2025.5.25 Accepted
The editors and chief editor are particularly responsible, the review process is very fast, unexpected, and the opinions of the two anonymous experts are also professional and in-depth.

(0) Thank | 简单点

I have been submitting my work for 10 days, but still no response.

(0) Thank | nanananna

Are there any submissions in May? How long does it take to be with the editor, and is it easier to be reviewed if the time is shorter?

(0) Thank | 11Accept!!

Has the expert reviewed your manuscript again after the second round of revisions? Currently, one expert has accepted the revision without any comments, while another expert has provided suggestions for publication after the revisions and has also given three additional recommendations. It is uncertain whether they will review it again or if the editor will make the final decision.

(0) Thank | 简单点

Have the experts reviewed your manuscript again after the second round of revisions? Currently, one expert has accepted it without any comments, while the other expert has provided suggestions for revisions and proposed three additional suggestions for publication. I am unsure if they will review it again or if the editor will make the final decision.

(0) Thank | 简单点

On the third day, RRC received the review comments, which required major revisions, and was given a deadline of one and a half months for revisions.

(0) Thank | KUGE

How long does RRC usually take?

(0) Thank | 简单点

4.12 The second review comments have been received, entering the RRC, hoping for a smooth process.

(0) Thank | KUGE

The classic journal of human geography seems to have been upgraded to the TOP level for the latest issue. I just had an article published there recently. My submission experience is as follows: the manuscript was sent for review the day after submission, the review process took about a month and a half, and if the opinions of two reviewers are received, it will wait for the opinion of a third reviewer. Some suggestions were quite similar, but they helped improve the overall quality of the article. The revised version was given a month for resubmission, and the decision was made on the same day that the opinions of the last two reviewers reached the RRC status. Dr. Wei is very efficient in handling submissions, as changes in the system status are generally processed within a day or two.

(0) Thank | KANAYOKI

Submitted on February 26, 2025
Rapid review on February 28, 2025
Four reviewers on March 2, 2025, one has accepted and returned
Reviewer 2 has not accepted the review yet, please be patient.

(0) Thank | KUGE

I have submitted to this journal before, and it went smoothly at the time. It was reviewed in a week, and after over a month, I received feedback. After revisions, it was accepted. However, I believe this submission experience was an exception. From the past to now, I have heard many friends in the geography field complain about submitting for 4-5 months with no response from the editor, and when they inquire via email, they are directly rejected. This is such an arrogant attitude! I hope the editors of this journal realize that good authors and good works are needed for a journal to be good. Otherwise, if people do not support it, the journal is nothing.

(0) Thank | ahaha233

Submitted on 25.1.09
Rejected on 25.2.20
Review 1 provided no feedback, only language expression issues; Review 3 suggested major revisions. Review 2 said the method was unreliable. However, this method has been used in 25 years of LANDUP and previously in CITIES, SCS. This reviewer is complete garbage! The editor didn't even give a chance to argue.

(0) Thank | bzcars

24.11.2 Health and Place rejected the recommendation for this journal.
24.11.3 Submission
24.11.8 Under Review

(0) Thank | 魏佳

Submission on 10.18
WE10.23-present

(0) Thank | 小鱼

2024.3.5 Submitted to journal
2024.3.12 Under review
2024.6.11 Review complete (2 reviewers)--Major revision
2024.7.21 Submitted revised manuscript
2024.8.14 Review complete --minor revision
2024.9.21 Submitted revised manuscript
2024.10.8 Review complete --minor revision
2024.10.15 Submitted revised manuscript
2024.10.18 Accepted

The journal editor is very responsible, and the expert opinions are professional and insightful. The revisions were challenging but significantly improved the article.

(0) Thank | yukine

So slow, one of the reviewers has not provided feedback after receiving the manuscript for review.

(0) Thank | keichiu

May I ask how long it usually takes to submit to "with editor"?

(0) Thank | Dr_Lucky_006

Submit on September 3, 2024, hoping for a faster processing.

(0) Thank | wang125

Don't submit to this journal anymore. It's tiring, no news for months. It's been under external review but no one is accepting submissions

(0) Thank | 平凡生活

Hello, have you received the editor's reply now?

(0) Thank | 在读研究生一枚

How are you? When did you receive it?

(0) Thank | 平凡生活