Fast speed, the reviewers are very friendly.

(0) Thank | kekelittlebear

It's really slow.
20250605, Submitted
20250612, assigned to Editor, Dr. Omar Azzaroni
20250622, still no change at Editor.

(0) Thank | azhou

Oh no, the editing has been assigned, but I can't tell if it has been reviewed or not.

(0) Thank | Xiaoyue Guo

Excuse me, has the editing been assigned? I have been waiting for 23 days and have not received any response.

(0) Thank | Xiaoyue Guo

Submission on 13th May 2025.
It's already 5th June 2025 and there's still no editor response, is this speed normal?

(0) Thank | Xiaoyue Guo

Hello, may I ask if your paper has been assigned an editor now?

(0) Thank | 风风风111

2025.1.20 Submission
2025.3.03 Major Revision (one major revision, two minor revisions)
2025.3.07 Resubmission after filling in the system
2025.4.07 Acceptance

(0) Thank | KIKI叮咚

25/3/25 submitted
25/4/08 not yet assigned editor

(0) Thank | Cestlavies

Has Dr. Sophie Guillaume replied to you?

(0) Thank | 12ee3

How are you doing? I am also an editor.

(0) Thank | 12ee3

Have you replied now? It's been almost two weeks for me as well.

(0) Thank | keyanxiaocai

It's been almost two weeks since the major revision was submitted and there is still no news. Hopefully, there will be good news soon.

(0) Thank | 小白du

After successfully appealing to the editor, the submission was sent for review within a week. The original reviewers were all persuaded and gave the opinion of direct acceptance without the need for revisions. The editor pointed out a minor formatting issue, which was fixed and returned on the same day, and the submission was officially accepted the next day. Love ACS, their efficiency is really high.

(0) Thank | ddddd0000

Yes, very slow, I don't know what's going on. Dr. Sophie Guillaume, who was assigned to me, has been completely quiet for half a month.

(0) Thank | Pim

Do submissions have to be in tex format?

(0) Thank | 小天使11

Brother, what's going on? I thought ACS was supposed to review papers quickly, but I'm also really nervous.

(0) Thank | keyanxiaocai

24/9/12 submitted
24/9/15 assigned with editor (Prof.Christoph Weder)
24/9/25 in peer review
No news yet, was hoping for quick and efficient publication by ACS, applying for funding by the end of the year, now there is no hope, just bad luck.

(0) Thank | lilkyleane

May I ask which editor is this?

(0) Thank | 舍夫沙万

Submission on September 2, 2024
First revision returned on September 30, 2024
Second revision returned on October 23, 2024
Third submission for format modification on November 2, 2024
Now waiting for news.

(0) Thank | WUjc3333

Resubmitted on the 15th of this month, it is now under review.

(0) Thank | zf

Have you resubmitted it already? Or are you looking for another journal? I successfully appealed last week and the editor agreed to allow resubmission.

(0) Thank | ddddd0000

I also submitted in March, with three reviewers, one negative and two positive. In the end, it was rejected, but they gave me the chance to resubmit.

(1) Thank | zf

Submission on October 15th, 2024.
Assigned to the editor on October 18th, 2024.
Now waiting for updates.

(0) Thank | zf

The review process was very quick, and the comments on the manuscript came back promptly as well. Two positive and one negative, that negative comment just didn't understand at all, didn't even read the article carefully. The reason for rejection is completely unfounded, but they still suggested rejection. Sigh, I have already written an email to appeal, hoping for a positive outcome. The editor is Professor Xuesong Jiang.

(0) Thank | ddddd0000

8/19 提交
8/19 副编辑分配
8/21 副编辑分配

Translated into English:
8/19 submitted
8/19 associate editor assigned
8/21 associate editor assigned

(0) Thank | 哈换