Submitted to acceptance took 40 days, one month for revision, both reviewers gave minor revisions, a total of 81 comments, accepted 4 days later.

(0) Thank | Xiong Liu

It's so miserable. Ever since the new editor took over, it's been so slow. Before, I could get accepted in an average of four to five months. Now I submitted a new one, and it has been 'we' all along, causing me trouble.

(0) Thank | 爱搞学术的小傻子

Hey, what's up? Have you sent an email to follow up?

(1) Thank | 园田真理老公

In two more days, it will be exactly one year. Major revisions were made once, minor revisions were made once, the second submission was completed in April, and the experts completed their review on May 17th. Up until now, the editors haven't even looked at it, and it's still in the "under review" status.

(0) Thank | 园田真理老公

How is the progress now? Have teachers and students submitted their contributions? How long does the initial review take?

(0) Thank | 爱搞学术的小傻子

5.28 accepted, one major revision and one minor revision in between; 
It took four and a half months from submission to acceptance, and waiting for two rounds of revisions for the review process, which seems quite long after 25 years. However, the editorial department processed it quite quickly after acceptance;
Wish everyone could be accepted.

(0) Thank | Tempo

4.9 Major revision
4.17 resubmitted to the journal
5.10 under review
The journal is moving at a snail's pace now, urging for submission is useless, endless torture~

(0) Thank | Leonard_THX

On May 27th, 2025, after waiting for a month and a half, the reviewer did not provide feedback on the revised manuscript. The editor decided to accept the submission.

(0) Thank | Paper_muggle

"Bro, we're in the same boat. I submitted my application in June, and it's been a year now. The expert review has been completed for four or five days, but the status is still UR..."

(0) Thank | 园田真理老公

RRC reminded the system to submit the draft after half a month, and three days after the reminder, the editor provided major revisions.

(0) Thank | 夏洛不烦恼

2025.4.27 submit
2025.5.22 approved

(0) Thank | PJF

2024-10-8: submit to journal
2024-10-19: UR

2025-3-2: Major
2025-3-18: Revision
2025-4-15: UR

(0) Thank | Paper_muggle

It's been half a month, I'm losing my mind, should I urge them?

(0) Thank | 夏洛不烦恼

The first instance

(0) Thank | 夏洛不烦恼

Can I ask if you are a first-instance or second-instance RRC?

(0) Thank | DASDASDQWDW

How long does the second-instance RRC typically take?

(0) Thank | DASDASDQWDW

Dear experts, it has been 10 days since RRC, should we follow up on it? How long does it usually take for RRC in this journal?

(0) Thank | 夏洛不烦恼

05.05接受

(0) Thank | Rom66

Hello, where is the payment link? Will it be sent together with the email or will it be sent separately later on?

(0) Thank | 学术届不缺我这一篇

When will the payment link be sent? Just received it, thank you.

(0) Thank | 学术届不缺我这一篇

Hello, where is this payment link located? I have just received it as well.

(0) Thank | 学术届不缺我这一篇

Is there any guidance on how many days to complete the payment upon receiving the invoice?

(0) Thank | 青花椒椒椒椒椒

04.22 under review

(0) Thank | lijingfei

Are you still here now? I voted on 4.7.

(0) Thank | 江洋

4.18 RRC 10-3-2
4.19 Under review 10-3-2

(0) Thank | HNKK