- Waiting for Revision
April 21, 23
- Decision Made
April 25, 23
- Under Consideration
March 22, 23
- Under Review
March 22, 23
- Submission
March 9, 23

(0) Thank | 海边拾贝

Overall, it is still good. The reviewers under Nature are very professional, having at least published in the journal before. The feedback they provide is also professional and constructive, as evident from the peer review process.

(0) Thank | 海边拾贝

The reviewers are very professional, having at least published in NC journals. Their feedback is also professional and objective, just like NC. You can tell just by looking at the peer review.

(0) Thank | 海边拾贝

It's quite normal, everything is normal for two to three weeks.

(0) Thank | 海边拾贝

No, it's more than 20,000 RMB. Cheaper than Nature Communication.

(0) Thank | 海边拾贝

Alright, alright, stop boasting.

(0) Thank | 漫天星辰花

A classmate submitted an article, which was later accepted for publication, and it turned out that the layout fee is 38,000 RMB!!!!!!

(0) Thank | 漫天星辰花

The difficulty level is similar to Nature Communications, but the subcategory is physics. If you check the reviewers in ORCID, you will know that the reviewers have at least published in Nature Physics, Nature Communications, and PRL.

(0) Thank | fdasfasdf

It has been a week since the editor was assigned, is this normal? Can any brother or sister provide some guidance?

(0) Thank | 猪猪大熊猫

In the PR series, it definitely can't compare to PRL and PRX, but it is slightly better than the other PR publications.

(0) Thank | HEDP

Will there be any changes in status details after "under review", or will it go directly to the editor's decision?

(0) Thank | Tsing1234

submission -> under review

(0) Thank | fdasfasdf

Brothers, have any of you submitted before? Can you share the process of submission status changes? I have been in the Submission status for my submission. What will happen next if it goes for review?

(0) Thank | Tsing1234

Winning an award doesn't mean you have to brag about it. It's not about self-aggrandizing, but rather about the quality of your work. If you are a serious physicist, ask yourself how many people actually think this journal is better than PRL. It's really awkward.

(0) Thank | oihoigo

The quality of the PR series articles fluctuates relatively greatly, with Communications Physics having an Impact Factor of around 6 in recent years and a published acceptance rate of around 30% (though the actual acceptance rate may be lower). The average level of its articles should be slightly higher than that of the PR series' Letters

(0) Thank | PRLKING

What is the quality level of this journal? Can it compare with the PR series?

(0) Thank | 数学物理

Nature Series Journals "Ladder" Diagram: General--->Subdivision--->General--->Subdivision--->Subdivision--->General, with both division and consolidation:
                                                          (General)  Nature
                          (Various disciplines) Nature Physics/Materials/Chemistry/Medicine/......
                                           (General) Nature Communications
               (Various disciplines) Communications Physics/Materials/Chemistry/Medicine/......
               (Various subdivided disciplines) Npj quantum materials/Computational Materials/......
                                                 (General) Scientific reports

(1) Thank | PRLKING

What is the level of this journal? Can it compare to the PR series?

(0) Thank | 数学物理

It is generally more difficult than NJP and the submission period is usually longer

(0) Thank | 荣神益人---是光是盐

How do you find the difficulty of this journal compared to NJP?

(0) Thank | 佐治

The level of this journal has been gradually improving and is currently slightly higher than the PR series Letters. Its position closely follows PRL and is classified as a first-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

(0) Thank | PRLKING

What level is this journal exactly?

(0) Thank | 数学物理

The niche biophysical topic, transferred from a small NC, received the first version of the review comments after three months, requiring major revisions, and the revised manuscript was accepted.

(0) Thank | Ryansss

Hello, can you please share some detailed information about the submission status?

(0) Thank | 数学物理

Hello, can you please share detailed information about the submission status?

(0) Thank | 数学物理