11.22 submitted; 11.23 with editor; 12.1 under review; 12.1 required review completed; 12.13 required review completed. Why did it become required review completed at the same day of under review, and then change to required review completed on 12.13? Thank you!

(2) Thank | 湘科院材料

The review is still fast, but I always feel that the editing speed is a bit slow. Submitted on July 9, with editor on July 11, under review on July 15, major revision required on July 28, and revision submitted on August 1. It waited five days before it was with editor, and then it was accepted directly on August 6. The point is, it was not online so far, and it is really very, very slow to be published.

(8) Thank | 小DU同学

@Upstairs rabbit, please don’t worry, this journal is still very fast. Let me talk about my submission time for your reference: on June 18th, submission, (without editor assigned); on June 24th, my submission number was not given yet, and it kept showing “submit to the journal”. I was worried that something went wrong during submission and I consulted Elsevier. On June 26th, the submission number came out, and it became under review at the same time. I assumed there's something wrong with the system. On July 7th, required reviews completed. It took 20 days from submission to the end of first review. On July 8th, major revisions were required. There were two reviewers.

(9) Thank | dc hu

Why are we still in WE after half a month of investment?

(0) Thank | Yamyoung

Hello, I did not see specific requirements for font, spacing, etc. on the journal's official website. How did you handle this? Looking forward to your reply, thank you very much!

(1) Thank | 记得开心1

Is it normal that I have been in the review status for two weeks and the reviewer has not accepted the review yet?

(0) Thank | dws5126

I have been in the "under review" status for two weeks now, and have not yet had a reviewer accept the manuscript. Is this normal?

(0) Thank | dws5126

Original：楼主 这么久才送审？？

Translation: OP, it took so long for you to submit for review??

(0) Thank | 木子李

It took so long to review?

(0) Thank | 木子李

2025.2.24 submitted to journal
2025.3.22 Two reviewers agree to revise
2025.4.12 Major revision
2025.4.26 Revision submitted to journal
2025.4.30 Accept

(0) Thank | Lewis Richard

This year our lab has already published two papers. Overall, the review process is slow, but the editorial handling is very fast.

First paper:
- Submitted on January 26, 2025, and sent for review about a week later
- Major revision requested on April 16, 2025 (review comments were relatively simple and not requiring major changes)
- Revised on April 24, 2025
- Under review on April 25, 2025
- Accepted on May 13, 2025
- Proofed on May 14, 2025
- Online on May 15, 2025

Second paper:
- Submitted on February 5, 2025, and sent for review about a week later
- Major revision requested on March 24, 2025 (several reviewers were consulted, eventually 17 were chosen, and their comments were fair and not extreme)
- Revised on April 5, 2025
- Received acceptance email after waking up on April 6, 2025
- Online on April 8, 2025
- Proofs on April 10, 2025, and final version published the next day.

(1) Thank | younger！

Submitted on March 24th, with editor on the same day
Revised on April 28th
Returned for revisions on May 8th
Accepted on May 16th
Thanks to editor-in-chief Hua-Xin Peng.

(1) Thank | luhongjie

Thank you to the editor-in-chief, Hua-Xin Peng.

(0) Thank | AnJing要潜水

Submitted on January 4
Reviews due on January 25
Received major revisions from two reviewers on March 16
Revised manuscript submitted on April 13
Accepted on April 17
Thanks to Editor Hu and the two reviewers.

(0) Thank | AnJing要潜水

3.20接受

(0) Thank | 张小

Don't email the author, I will ask the teacher later.

(0) Thank | 张小

It can be confirmed that the editor was busy writing funds before and didn't pay attention to us. Just checked, it was accepted.

(0) Thank | 小Qzzz

No updates, no response at all, check my email 10 times a day.

(0) Thank | 张小

If it's not updated, and it doesn't change this month, I'll remind them.

(0) Thank | 张小

Brother, has the status been updated? Mine is also P edited.

(0) Thank | 小Qzzz

I see that most are accepted for rework on the same day or the next day, why is it so slow when it comes to us? Is it because the editors are busy applying for funding recently? I give up.

(0) Thank | 小Qzzz

There is no movement at all, I am also speechless, it's too slow.

(0) Thank | 张小

I can't see which editor it is, do you have any updates now?

(0) Thank | 小Qzzz

The status hasn't changed, I see the front journals are quite fast, are you the P editor?

(0) Thank | 张小

Has the status been updated? I am also in the 3.5 with editor for rework, and it has not been updated yet. I am feeling so anxious o(╥﹏╥)o.

(0) Thank | 小Qzzz