7.12, submission; It was under review in 4 days; 8.16, the revision comments were received. There were 4 reviewers and many comments. However, there was no need to supplement the experience; 9.12, the revised manuscript was submitted; 9.22, the revision comments were received again. There were 2 reviewers and 9 comments; 9.25, the revised manuscript was submitted again; 9.27, accepted.

(2) Thank | Petermu35

I used to browse others’ submission experience before, so let me share something today. 2020.1.6 first submission, 2020.1.10 sent for review, 2020.2.3 receive rejection letter. There was only one reviewer who gave a lot of comments. Both the editor and the reviewer indicated that I can resubmit it after revision. The reviewer’s comments were clear and pertinent. I perfected the manuscript according to the questions. I resubmitted the manuscript on March 19, 2020. It was Decision in Process less than two weeks after Under Review. Review comments returned a few days later. Two reviewers made some suggestions for revision. I made corresponding revision and resubmitted it. It was accepted on April 28, 2020.

(3) Thank | 波上寒烟

2019.09.21, submission; 2019.10.26, major revision; 2019.12.22, revision submitted. 2020.01.29, minor revision; 2020.03.03, accept. I remember that I used to come to the comments section to see other people's experience after submission and count the time of my own article. Now I also share my own experience, for the students to refer to the (writing of) first article in the future, thank you.

(4) Thank | 喵子

The length of the review period is very inconsistent for this journal; it could be anywhere from one month to over 7 months. This suggests that the review process is solely the responsibility of the reviewer; I’m not sure if the editor directly reminds the reviewers or provides deadlines. In short, its luck if you have a fast review cycle.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The rejection was received on August 2nd Beijing time, but we can resubmit quickly.

(0) Thank | 火花骑士可莉

"Beijing time on the morning of July 28 (July 27 in the United States) Sub to Jor
Beijing time on July 29
Beijing time on the morning of July 30 WE"

(0) Thank | 火花骑士可莉

After stable Zone 3 and experimental Zone 2 were both rejected, I am still very grateful that it was accepted. I feel the whole process is very standardized and the speed is also acceptable.
April 30投；
May 11 UR；
May 26 RRC；
June 2 Reviews Complete, Revise, with 3 reviewers, each providing seven or eight comments, one providing more than ten. Overall, it is very professional, and it feels like precise peer reviewers were selected. The revised manuscript is due on July 3; I really cherish this opportunity and will work hard on the revisions.
July 2 Revised manuscript submitted;
July 3 UR;
July 12 Accept

(0) Thank | lituozi

How long does the repair take?

(0) Thank | 六便士y

Is there no process with the editor?

(0) Thank | 六便士y

Not bad, I have met the graduation requirements. The review period is neither fast nor slow, submitted on October 4th and accepted on January 4th, with each period lasting about a month.

(0) Thank | hopeman

I am still waiting for another reviewer to review my revised manuscript. It has been almost half a month.

(0) Thank | hopeman

This is outrageous.

(0) Thank | hopeman

I'm done. It took three weeks for the editors to review the submission, and then there was no news for a whole month after it was sent for review. Another month passed before it was finally reviewed, only to be rejected.

(0) Thank | 等晴空

Submitted on 3rd December 2024, it has been "with editor" status until 9th December. I don't know when it will be reviewed. Praying! I am anxious to graduate.

(0) Thank | 陈陈同学

I only submit to journals with good reviews, but recently the review process has been quite slow. After submitting for the first time, it took nearly a month for the manuscript to be sent out for review. It has been ten days since then and there is still no reviewer assigned.

(0) Thank | 等晴空

7.11 Submit
7.28 Provide revisions
8.7 Revise
8.17 Accept
Very fast turnaround!

(0) Thank | Fance

This status was sent for review in just over a week. My rework was received the next day.

(0) Thank | yizhuozzz

Hello, I would like to ask how long the wait time is typically for the with editor stage, and if there will be any results during this stage.

(0) Thank | wangshengding

Submitted on 6.21, reviewed on 6.28, minor revisions on 7.14, returned on 7.29, one reviewer requested image modifications on 8.8, another agreed to accept, minor revisions, returned on 8.9. Waiting for the results.

(0) Thank | yizhuozzz

I read a lot of comments and experiences here before submitting my first article. Here is my timeline for reference:

3.10 Submitted
3.13 Under Review
3.19 Required Reviews Complete (Editor invited 7 reviewers, 2 agreed to review, then editor invited 6 more reviewers, none agreed, but the first 2 reviewers completed their reviews)
3.25 Review Complete, received revision suggestions
4.2 Returned with Editor revisions
4.3 Accept

The overall speed was quite fast. I was in a hurry to graduate and was constantly rushing. I was afraid I wouldn't make it in time. From submission to acceptance in less than a month

(0) Thank | 七月窗台的猫

It's been two weeks and it still hasn't been submitted for review. The first time I submitted it, it was quite fast, but this time it's so slow

(0) Thank | Alicehyz

Hello, I would like to ask how long it took for you to review my submission from the time of submission. This question is important to me because it is required by my school. I hope you understand.

(0) Thank | yolo-jia

Hello, I would like to ask how long it took you from submitting to review? I'm sorry to bother you, and I hope you can reply.

(0) Thank | yolo-jia

Hello, I would like to ask how long it took for you to submit and review this journal? Sorry to bother you.

(0) Thank | yolo-jia

Doing academia for 5 years, this is the most frustrating time. I invited six reviewers, and they all agreed to review. In the end, only four reviewers came back, with two major revisions, one acceptance, and one minor revision. The editor rejected me... rejected me!!!!!! My life is ruined. Where is the justice? Where is fairness?

(1) Thank | 小方的打工仔