A total of 3 months was spent from submission to acceptance, with one major revision required in the middle, but it was published quickly after the acceptance. There were three reviewers, one suggested a minor revision, two suggested major revisions, and final a major revision was required. The reviewers had professional opinions, and the questions raised are helpful to improve the quality of the article. 2020.08.14 submitted to the journal; 2020.08.22 under review; 2020.09.22 major revision; 2020.10.26 revision submitted to journal; 2020.11.20 accepted; 2020.12.09 available online.

(3) Thank | L^_^

The submission period is 3 months, and 1 major revision was required. Thanks to Professor Leroy Gardner, Professor Jason Maxwell Ingham and the three reviewers for their suggestions and opportunities! We must make persistent efforts to publish valuable works! 2020.08.06 submitted to journal; 2020.08.13 with editor; 2020.09.21 major revision; 2020.10.12 revision submitted to journal; 2020.11.03 accepted.

(2) Thank | huazi

It took 6 months from submission to acceptance, and there were 3 major revisions. I am very grateful to Professor Leroy Gardner for giving me the opportunity for revision. I wish you all the best. 2020.03.18, submitted to journal; 2020.03.24, with editor; 2020.04.05, under review; 2020.04.19, major revision; 2020.04.23, revision submitted to journal; 2020.04.23, with editor; 2020.05.03, under review; 2020.05.05, required reviews completed; 2020.05.05, major revision (due: 2020.06.04); 2020.05.31, with editor; 2020.05.31, under review; 2020.07.05, major revision; 2020.07.15, with editor; 2020.09.14, accepted.

(114) Thank | fendourenshenghitmm

I followed up once yesterday and once today. It's too slow. I look forward to being rejected so I can submit to the next journal.

(0) Thank | Acc_Nyq

Usually two reviewers are enough.

(0) Thank | MATIN_LK

2025.3.5 submitted
2025.3.26 with editor
2025.4.3 under review
2025.5.2 major revise
2025.5.9 submitted revised manuscript
2025.6.16 accept

(1) Thank | MATIN_LK

The timeline is exactly the same as the OP's, it's really too slow.

(0) Thank | freak

I rated 6.5, I guess your submission has been reviewed before it's my turn. I really can't stand it, it's too slow.

(0) Thank | Acc_Nyq

2025.6.2, stj
2025.6.9, we
2025.6.16, we
Anxiety................

(0) Thank | D

June 16, 2025. Major revision with 8 opinions, within 28 days.

(0) Thank | 心碎的酸菜

May I ask if you sent any reminder emails during this period to urge for submission?

(0) Thank | accept-accept

2025.4.21, stj
2025.4.30, we
2025.6.14, ur (5-1-0)

(0) Thank | Cessy

To [Iceberg-zzzz] I feel it's all luck...

(0) Thank | 心碎的酸菜

6.11 RRC

(0) Thank | 心碎的酸菜

2025.5.1 submit
2025.5.7 with editor
2025.6.12 Still with editor, contacted customer service three times, each time they said they would help contact the editor, but there has been no progress. It's really frustrating.

(0) Thank | 早日毕业！

How can I withdraw a submission from this journal? Please send an email.

(0) Thank | 老梨

Depending on luck, it took me nearly 5 months to get approved last year.

(0) Thank | 什么时候能accept

I would like to ask, for the 6.4 invitation for peer review, we currently have two reviewers who have accepted. Do we need to wait for the third reviewer to accept, and how long does peer review typically take?

(0) Thank | 达文西达文西

Oh, you got rejected. I followed up a few days ago, but there has been no response yet. I'm really fed up with this journal.

(0) Thank | 旭

Why are you so fast? I have been with the editor for a month.

(0) Thank | Iceberg_zzzz

I don't know, but it feels pretty fast.

(0) Thank | 心碎的酸菜

Submitted on the same day, but it won't be the same editor, right?

(0) Thank | 12258366

2025.05.26 stj
2025.6.4 with editor
2025.6.4 under review

(0) Thank | 心碎的酸菜

This is too ridiculous, I am so nervous.

(0) Thank | dfiabhfjbhdfuia

The article has been stuck in the editor's hands for two months. After urging for a response, it was rejected, with the reason being that the analysis was not thorough enough. Why didn't they reject it earlier? It wasted my time.

(0) Thank | 哈哈