7.15, submitted; 7.20, under review; 9.30, under review (the status didn’t change, but the time changed, and it had not changed for more than two months); 10.2, required reviews completed. I will continue to update later. I'm not sure about these status or date changes, and I hope someone from my predecessors or colleagues can give me advice.

(3) Thank | J博士欧文

My luck is relatively good, let me share the experience; I hope it helps. 2020.5.13, submitted to journal; 2020.5.14, under review; 2020.6.29, major revision; 2020.7.20, the review comments were returned; 2020.8.15, accepted. Generally speaking, it was very fast. My editor is the editor-in-chief. After submission, it was sent for review on the next day.

(3) Thank | gaogaoago

I feel that the reviewers that the editor found are not very professional, and there are few suggestions for the content of the article. Most of the comments put forward are problems with figure labeling, or the problem of graphic and its corresponding text. A reviewer may not understand the pain points of the traditional products on the market. He can’t get my innovative ideas, gave some suggestions that of no importance, and rejected the manuscript. Another reviewer's suggestions for the content of the article are wrong suggestions based on not understanding the result analysis. I don’t know how the editor finds the reviewers. They seemed not to be very professional. I don’t know if it was because of my bad luck, and it happened to encounter two rejections from irresponsible reviewers.

(1) Thank | 科研小民工

Update the timeline, thank you to Professor Yao and the two reviewers. Generally speaking, the process will be quite fast if the reviewers do not disappear.

2024.10.30 STJ
2024.11.08 UR (15 invited, 5 accepted, 2 completed)
2025.3.29 DIP
2025.4.3 Major
2025.4.13 Resubmit
2025.4.20 UR
2025.4.29 Accepted

(0) Thank | Wiruky

I have been accepted for publication. Thank you to the editors of JBE journal. I hope the journal continues to improve.

(0) Thank | SCI一投就中

I am too, just always we.

(0) Thank | xiaoyuan.

In different directions, some are particularly slow, we are normal for a month, some directions are submitted for review on the same day, there is no way but to wait, can urge after a month, but it is not useful.

(0) Thank | 晴天娃娃2022

2025.02.27 Submitted
2025.03.05 Under review
2025.03.30 Revise
2025.04.11 Submitted
2025.04.21 Accepted

(0) Thank | 昆工zk

What should we do now? If we keep...

(0) Thank | xiaoyuan.

Why is it still "we" for several days and neither refusing nor submitting for review?

(0) Thank | xiaoyuan.

I also voted. How long has it been since we did? It has been several days now.

(0) Thank | xiaoyuan.

I have been 10 days and haven't submitted for review yet.

(0) Thank | 晓晓

Yes, accepting display until the end is 21.

(0) Thank | karna

Does the 21 days start counting from when you accept the review?

(0) Thank | 同济小水手

I remember when I reviewed it before, it was 21. Maybe I remembered it wrong.

(0) Thank | karna

Is the JBE first review time 21 days or 28 days? Is it calculated from the date the expert accepts the manuscript for review, or from the date the editor sends out the invitation?

(0) Thank | 同济小水手

4.21 1/2/18 Isn't the time given by the reviewer always 21 days?

(0) Thank | karna

After a little revision, the article has finally been revised and resubmitted. I pray that I won't have to revise it again. I put a lot of effort into writing this article, and my graduation depends on it.

(0) Thank | SCI一投就中

On the same day with editor, third day under review.

(0) Thank | 呵呵哒199

This has been too long.

(0) Thank | 呵呵哒199

I have been 25 days.

(0) Thank | Nuyoah-

How long does it take for this journal with editor?

(0) Thank | 呵呵哒199

The first review has been with the editor for 25 days, why hasn't it been sent for review yet? Are there any friends who have experienced similar situations?

(0) Thank | Nuyoah-

How do we deal with this, we are all on the verge of breaking down.

(0) Thank | SCI一投就中

My paper is also undergoing a second review (minor revisions), and I have submitted it for external review. However, the external reviewer has not accepted the manuscript for review yet, and it has been one month already. How should we handle this?

(0) Thank | SCI一投就中