The manuscript was sent for review after 2 months of with editor. It took more than 4 months to review the manuscript. In the end, the manuscript was rejected because the direction was inconsistent. It was delayed for more than half a year. It is too deceiving...

(5) Thank | 风中的云

Don’t send an email to the first floor, I was wrong, I received several emails each day asking me. I didn’t say my article was accepted. The acceptance situation was randomly selected; my article was still under review at that time, and the result had not been released. It has been rejected now. So, please don’t ask me. I will not reply to the emails, so, please don’t send emails. If you have any questions, just comment here.

(0) Thank | Accept！

Why no one commented on this journal? If you want to submit, you may email me at 1904272yao@gmail.com, and we can discuss about it.

(4) Thank | Accept！

Why has DIP been silent for eight days?

(0) Thank | 小兮594

2024.12.21 Submission
2024.12.21 WE
2024.12.24 WE
2024.12.25 Under Review (Reviewer 2/5)
2024.12.26 Under Review (Reviewer 1/2/5)
2024.12.28 Under Review (Reviewer 1/3/5)
2025.1.15 Under Review (Reviewer 2/3/5)
2025.1.17 RRC (Required Revisions Completed)
2025.1.22 Revise
2025.2.5 Revision Submitted to Journal
2025.2.10 WE
2025.3.27 Editor invited
2025.3.31 17.23 Under Review
2025.4.1 Under Review (Reviewer 3/3/1)
2025.4.11 Under Review (Reviewer 3/3/2)
2025.4.23 RRC
2025.4.25 DIP (Decision in Progress)

This status has been ongoing until today, the first time seeing DIP for over a week, probably sent.

(0) Thank | 小兮594

The speed is relatively slow.

(0) Thank | 小兮594

I have also encountered such a problem, how should I deal with it? Accept did not send an email, and I don't know how to handle it.

(0) Thank | Red13

Accepted, but how do we pay the layout fee? Does anyone know?

(1) Thank | 时光机

Hello, may I ask how do you pay your page charges? Is it done by the editorial office sending a link to the corresponding author?

(0) Thank | 时光机

How do you pay the publication fee? Is it through the link sent by the editorial department to the corresponding author?

(0) Thank | 时光机

I guess your eic is cuicui blindly.

(0) Thank | 爱吃花生的猫咪

Overall, the quality is acceptable.

(0) Thank | Moon of sky

Over the course of 11 months, there was a major revision followed by a minor revision, fortunately it was finally accepted for publication.
June 2024 Submitted
June 2024 WE
July 2024 UR
October 2024 Reviewed, with 4 reviewers
October 2024 Major revision, took 2 months with 29 comments
November 2024 Resubmitted for revision
November 2024 UR
February 2025 Reviewed, with 3 reviewers
February 2025 Minor revision, took 2 months
March 2025 Resubmitted for revision
April 2025 Accepted

(1) Thank | Moon of sky

Is there any result? I am also in the same situation.

(0) Thank | tianye

Have you received the feedback on your review? I am in the same situation.

(0) Thank | tianye

The first reviewer will finish in two weeks. The second reviewer will finish in three days. Then we will wait for the editor to handle it.

(0) Thank | submission

All five reviewers' comments have been received. How long is the review process expected to take?

(0) Thank | Eason Wh

Apr 01, 2025 Submission
Apr 01, 2025 Under Review
Nine reviewers have been invited, but none have accepted the review.

(0) Thank | 1001p

I waited for all five people to return, and only RRC, not RC, has returned to this journal.

(0) Thank | submission

May I ask how long it takes for reviewers to accept?

(0) Thank | 只爱accept

How long does it usually take for reviewers to accept the review invitation for the journal? We have sent out 7 review invitations, but it has been a week and none of the reviewers have accepted the invitation.

(0) Thank | 只爱accept

I am also one of the five reviewers, and I have completed two reviews that are still under review. How many reviewers does this journal require to complete the review?

(0) Thank | Eason Wh

I want to inquire about an issue. I previously submitted an article to a journal with Professor A as the corresponding author, but it was rejected. Later, I conducted some experiments and the corresponding author changed to Professor B. Can I submit the article again?

(0) Thank | 她说为了中非友谊

It has been a month and a half since the revision, but no reviewers have accepted the revised manuscript. Does anyone know what will happen in this situation? The revision suggestions are very good, but the reviewers have not accepted the revised manuscript, and urging the editors has been ineffective.

(0) Thank | Abilee

Tell me the title of the article and I will help you check the progress.

(0) Thank | mrd