May 24, 2025 Submitted
May 25, 2025 Under Review

(0) Thank | luoji

Incredibly slow!!!!!! I won't even mention the front part. The opinions of the two reviewers in the first review were okay, but after the revisions, there was no news at all. After the editor urged, the expert who gave easy-to-implement suggestions rejected them, while the expert who gave difficult suggestions accepted them. The revised manuscript was submitted on September 20th, and so far there has been no news at all, as if it had sunk into the sea (that expert! If you want to reject, just reject it straightforwardly, instead of dragging it out and doing nothing. When the editor urges him, he just directly rejects it, really disgusting).

(0) Thank | QQ_GG

With editor 26 Dec 2024
I have been waiting for a long time to apply.

(0) Thank | 赖皮的小白

Received at Editorial Office 5 Mar 2024
Article revised 28 Sep 2024
Article accepted for publication 27 Oct 2024

The journal itself seems to be quite diligent. After the article was reviewed, reviewers were asked to provide feedback within a month. However, due to the journal's influence, it seems that many people are reluctant to spend time reviewing for them. It took a long time to find reviewers for this article, and the status was often updated during the review process. It is speculated that this was caused by the editor inviting new reviewers. The article was submitted in March and the review was completed at the end of August. Overall, the speed was quite slow, but the editorial office's speed was acceptable. The article was accepted immediately after revisions, which was a bit unexpected!

(1) Thank | Love Accepted

Submitted on July 25, 2024, revised on September 12, and accepted on October 25. Overall, it went quite smoothly!

(1) Thank | maoyi12

Submitted manuscript on August 4th, 2021;
Assigned reference number on August 9th, 2021;
Received first review comments, major revisions, from two reviewers on November 12th, 2021;
Received second review comments, minor revisions, from two reviewers on January 14th, 2022;
Accepted on January 23rd, 2022;
Proofread on February 3rd, 2022;
Published on February 9th, 2022;
Took 7 months in total, with a moderate speed. The reviewers were very responsible and provided many constructive suggestions. Wishing the journal continued success.

(0) Thank | 研小白