Hello, what is the submission URL of "Engineering Construction and Architectural Management"? The link given here cannot be displayed normally when clicking the submission button. The information hasn’t been renewed.

(0) Thank | sunflowerLP

The article was submitted in September and accepted in June next year. During the period, it was delayed by myself for 2 months. It took about more than half a year in total.

(1) Thank | X

Yes, if the reviewer rejects the manuscript, it will revert back to the selection stage.

(1) Thank | 小心翼翼

Hello, after the first round of revisions, my status changed suddenly from "Awaiting Referee Response" to "Awaiting Referee Selection". What does this mean? Does it mean that the original referee rejected the manuscript and a new referee is being sought? Feeling anxious.

(0) Thank | Guoxiaobinger

Hello, may I ask what does it mean when the status changes from Awaiting Referee Response to Awaiting Referee Selection after the first review revision? Does it mean the original referee rejected the review and a new referee needs to be found?

(0) Thank | Guoxiaobinger

Hello, I would like to inquire about the change in status from "Awaiting Referee Response" to "Awaiting Referee Selection" after the first round of revisions. What does this mean? Does it indicate that the original referee has declined and a new referee is being sought? I am feeling anxious.

(0) Thank | Guoxiaobinger

Hey guys, when submitting a paper to ECAM, how is the counting of composite figures done? Do we count each figure separately or do we count them as one single figure?

(0) Thank | quin233

How long did it take you to submit for review in the end?

(0) Thank | leochu1929

2024-10-17 Major Revision
The previous reviewer 1 gave a major revision again, and reviewer 2 accepted it. Feeling exhausted, reviewer 1 saw the modifications made by reviewer 2 in the response section, and raised new questions based on these modifications. Reviewer 1's comments were quite vague, mentioning that some parameters were not explained clearly, but without specifying which ones.
2024-11-26 Awaiting Referee Invitation
2024-11-26 Awaiting Referee Response
2024-11-27 Awaiting Referee Scores
2024-12-05 Awaiting DE Decision
2024-12-07 Accept

(2) Thank | 417_cy

2024-07-09 Submission
2024-07-15 Awaiting Referee Selection
(Through editorial pre-review, editor is looking for referees)
2024-07-16 Awaiting Referee Response
2024-08-07 Awaiting Referee Selection
(Referee declined review, editor is selecting new referees)
2024-08-11 Awaiting Referee Response
2024-09-01 Awaiting Referee Scores
2024-09-04 Major Revision
(Editor has chosen two referees, both recommend major revisions with a 3-month deadline)
(Main recommendations from referees focus on the discussion section, requesting more content, expanded applications, or policy suggestions; next most common are about the model section, asking for detailed explanations of the model and case backgrounds)
2024-10-12 Awaiting Referee Invitation
2024-10-12 Awaiting Referee Response
2024-10-13 Awaiting Referee Scores

(2) Thank | 417_cy

How are you now, have you been hired?

(0) Thank | 好运连连001

I submitted my paper in mid-May this year, and it was returned for major revisions after about a month of review. It took me around 2 months to make the necessary revisions. After resubmitting, it took another two months for the paper to be reviewed again. I sent an email to follow up during this period, and soon after, it was accepted on October 14th.

(0) Thank | Aswan1

I want to ask how long everyone has been in the status of checking permissions. It has been 40 days for me and I am still in this status. Is this a normal phenomenon?

(0) Thank | 必中好几篇

Submission rejected after 4 months.
Two reviewers provided feedback, reviewer 1 rejected the submission, reviewer 2 suggested minor revisions, but the editor ultimately rejected it.
In my opinion, reviewer 1 was arrogant and conceited, their main reason for rejection being that my problem could be solved using existing method A and my method B was not necessary.
I wrote an appeal letter, requesting the editor to consider sending it to a third reviewer, but my request was denied.
Lastly, I want to say that I am not unable to accept the rejection decision. In the past, rejection was only disappointing, but this time it feels particularly offensive and angering.
Please consider it for yourselves.

(0) Thank | fffff1111

Submit on October 11, 2024
Editorial review on October 26, 2024
Currently waiting for reviewer selection.

(0) Thank | ihdeswoi

Submission Experience:
9/4/2024 Submitted
9/18/2024 Pre-screened by editor
Currently still in "Awaiting Referee Selection" status, it has been one and a half months, with no changes in status. Sent an inquiry email and waiting for reply.

(0) Thank | lemon

The second submission stayed on the EA checklist for two weeks, which is also impressive speed.

(0) Thank | 珂酱

I have always chosen non-OA. This is just a double confirmation, you can change it, even if you initially chose non-OA, you can change it to OA later. It is the same principle as the situation mentioned.

(0) Thank | 珂酱

Have you chosen non-oa for your submission? Does the editor say that a re-review is needed?

(0) Thank | 小ok

One minor revision, one rejection, and ultimately rejected...

(0) Thank | 搬砖法师

Have you chosen non-OA for your submission? Has the editor approved it? Or do you need to have it reviewed again?

(0) Thank | 小ok

No, this is just to confirm if you still want to choose OA. How long is your review period in total?

(0) Thank | 珂酱

Before the paper is accepted, I selected "Yes, I want to publish my article as Open Access," but after receiving the email informing me that my manuscript has been accepted, I would like to change to "No, I don't want to publish Open Access." Should the journal reconsider accepting my paper?

(0) Thank | Aswan1

The option chosen before the paper was accepted was "Yes, I want to publish my article as Open Access," but after acceptance, I would like to change to non-OA "No, I don't want to publish Open Access." Should the journal reconsider accepting my paper?

(0) Thank | Aswan1

May I ask, before my paper was accepted, I selected "Yes, I want to publish my article as Open Access", but after acceptance I want to change to non-OA "No, I don't want to publish Open Access", does the journal need to reconsider whether to accept my paper or not?

(0) Thank | Aswan1