10-4 Delivery
10-15 Letter of Introduction and WeChat ID required
10-28 Awaiting reviewer selection
10-29 Awaiting Reviewer Comments
10-30 Last modified
12-2 Last modified
12-2 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
12-24 Awaiting Reviewer Comments
12-28 Last modified
1-6 Last modified
1-18 Last modified
1-19 Last modified
3-5 Major revision

round two
3-12 Awaiting reviewer selection
3-15 Awaiting Reviewer Comments
3-17 Last modified
3-18 Last modified
3-20 Last modified
3-22 Minor revision

3-24 Accept

(0) Thank | 冲ccccc

About a month later, I waited for a while before it turned into waiting for the reviewer's comments. After five or six months, it became waiting for the selection of reviewers. After this major revision, a month later, it became waiting for the selection of reviewers again. I have no idea about the specific review process of the journal, and I am completely confused.

(0) Thank | wangchao

May I ask how long it usually takes for "awaiting reviewer selection"?

(0) Thank | xixi0816

I invested at the end of May in the 24th year, waited for 9 months, and the major repair was not given until February of the 25th year. The repair was returned at the end of February, it has been a month now, and I am still waiting for the results. I don't know how long I have to wait.

(0) Thank | wangchao

Received and payment completed on March 10th.

(0) Thank | 板栗ko

Could you please confirm if the first reviewer I found previously has now become the first reviewer to search for again, with a gap of about half a month? Is it possible that the first reviewer has declined the review? Oh no.

(0) Thank | 邓文卓

24.8 submit 25. received pre-acceptance email.

(0) Thank | 噢哈哈哈哈哈噢

2025-2-21 Received payment notice. Just hoping the new division of the Chinese Academy of Sciences at the end of February will not cut too harshly.

(0) Thank | houqy

On February 10, 2025, the feedback returned with another major revision, with 3 reviewers and 1 suggestion accepted. There were a total of 11 comments, which seemed manageable. Hopefully, this round of revisions will be completed quickly and the manuscript can be accepted for publication.

(0) Thank | 板栗ko

Hey, I wanted to ask how much is the publishing fee, plus any additional fees for editing?

(0) Thank | Lucky_accept

24.8 submission. 9.30 first revision, 11.7 second revision, 24.12 acceptance, 25.1 online. The editor has a good attitude and is very patient.

(0) Thank | lucas

Initiated on November 14, 2024
Last modified on January 15, 2025

(0) Thank | houqy

I made a slight change and then filled out the form.

(0) Thank | 板栗ko

The major revision submitted on 11/19, which was waiting, has now turned into "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" again today. It's too slow.

(0) Thank | 板栗ko

The editor provided a major revision, with feedback from two reviewers totaling six suggestions. Does anyone know if the editor really wants the entire article structure to be reorganized, or is it enough to just fill out the two requested forms?

(0) Thank | 噢哈哈哈哈哈噢

Date submitted: 2024-10-22
Initiated: 2024-10-22
Last modified: 2024-11-18
The status is still Awaiting Reviewer Selection, it's too slow.

(0) Thank | houqy

4.11: Submit
4.17: Request for recommendation letter submission
4.22: Submit recommendation letter
7.3: Received email with comments on major revisions, including checklist requirements
7.19: Submit major revisions
8.14: Received email indicating potentially acceptable status, including comments from minor revisions reviewers and editor, as well as COI requirements
8.26: Submit minor revisions
9.11: Received email for detail modifications and submitted on the same day
9.12: Received acceptance email, including payment details
9.18: Completed payment and replied via email
9.19: Received confirm the receipt email
10.15: Received proofreading email and replied on the same day
10.22: Received online email
12.5: Officially publication

(0) Thank | Co Sherry

Feedback is timely, attitude is friendly, and the process is rigorous and meticulous.

(0) Thank | Co Sherry

8 opinions, not sure how many reviewers.

(0) Thank | 板栗ko

How many reviewers are there and how many comments are there in total?

(0) Thank | 咩water

10.30 Return to major revision suggestions One of the editing issues is that I need to reorganize the article according to his list, which feels quite challenging...

(1) Thank | 板栗ko

How should I go about using PayPal?

(0) Thank | 仲夏初之

How is the situation now?

(0) Thank | 晨风新儿

Congratulations, there are basically no problems up to this point.

(0) Thank | Esther Vaughan

Hello, I have now made the third round of revisions to the email and it has been accepted.

(0) Thank | 仲夏初之