In this case, the review speed was really too slow. The article was submitted in the June 2018. It showed it was received in July, and the review started. The first round of review was not finished until the end of December 2019. It took about one year and a half during the period. But fortunately, the comments raised by the two review experts were relatively good, and each one raised about 6 comments. One reviewer suggested to accept it after revision, and the other one required major revision. The editor required major revision, and it was required to be returned in a month after revision. However, one month was too short, and it was revised for 3 months. The revised manuscript was submitted at the beginning of March in 2020. And the acceptance was displayed in 3 days.

(53) Thank | yjysxbzj

This journal is really speechless. Submitted on 2018.05.09, and it directly displayed as archived on 2020.04.25. There was no opinion, or anything. Well, a total of two years! I sent several letters to the editor and editor-in-chief in the middle, but none of them got replied. It’s the same situation as the 8th poster. I really can’t help registering an account here to complain...

(5) Thank | ljptp

Most people who submitted for this journal just for graduation, right? Generally, the quality of the articles submitted to this journal is not good. In addition, the journal has no reputation and is only indexed by SCIE. If you are anxious to graduate, it is not recommended to submit.

(1) Thank | 羊小羊

Submitted in early July 2017, and the displayed status was archived by mid-August 2018. I wrote to the editorial office to ask if it had rejected the manuscript; I sent two emails but got no reply. I feel that the journal editor is not responsive, and the review is extremely slow. I have still not received any news from the editorial office (November 2, 2018). Even if you have rejected the manuscript, you have to tell the authors clearly, and it is normal to explain the reason for the rejection. This journal does not explicitly state the rejection of the manuscript, nor does it give any explanation for the manuscript processing (only displayed "archived", I feel that my manuscript had just been sitting in the editorial office for ten months (no way to know if the paper has been reviewed). So I can only think that it was rejected. Please be cautious when submitting to this journal.

(5) Thank | pure water

I submitted my work in January 25th and on May 7th the status changed to "in editing". The editor at the review stage decided to accept the submission. I have not gone through the editing stage yet. Can you tell me what my current status is?

(0) Thank | 九八18

Hello, how are you doing now? I am in a similar situation as you.

(0) Thank | 九八18

投的 in September 2024.

(0) Thank | HL

Initiated on 2025-02-25
Last modified on 2025-05-07
Uploaded file: None
Editor Decision: Nothing

Is this for external review? Or what is the status?

(0) Thank | HL

Can you please confirm my current status is "In Editing"? I opened the Review page to decide where to display "accept submission", but I have not gone through the process of review and revisions. What is my current status now?

(0) Thank | 九八18

Hello, how are you doing right now? I am in the same state, but I have not gone through the rework yet. The status is in editing, and when I click into Review, it shows accept submission.

(0) Thank | 九八18

It's been one year since submission, haha, no news at all.

(0) Thank | 早日毕业

Hello, are you uploading repair feedback at the place mentioned downstairs?

(0) Thank | Homleeeeeee

This status means that you have been accepted. Waiting for them to contact you for proofreading and payment. I waited for a whole year before, and then I called the editorial department, and they immediately arranged for proofreading and payment. If I had continued to wait, who knows when I would have heard back. Now it has become Zone 3 again. When I submitted, it was Zone 2, but it has been over a year, and now it is Zone 3 when accepted. Fortunately, it has returned to Zone 2 when published, now~~~

(0) Thank | zseason

Hello, may I ask if the article has been finalized? Has it been submitted in the system? Is it here?

(0) Thank | MingLiSCI

Hello, may I ask where to upload the revised manuscript? Is it uploaded here? Why hasn't the status changed after I uploaded it?

(0) Thank | MingLiSCI

Hello, may I ask where to upload the revised manuscript and response letter? I can't find the upload location, should I send it to the author via email?

(0) Thank | MingLiSCI

Submitted on April 28, 2024
Assignment turned in for review on July 2, 2024
Still under review to this day
Last modified on August 29, 2024

(0) Thank | 早日毕业

My situation is the same. What does "Accept Submission" mean?

(0) Thank | 小非文子

My time is about the same as yours, just a little earlier. I am in the same situation and would like to know if any knowledgeable teachers can provide an answer.

(0) Thank | HL

Hello, my situation is the same. May I ask if I have been hired? Where should I pay the layout fee?

(0) Thank | 一个昵称而已

It has been over two months since In review, and the Initiated time and last modified time in the Peer Review section of In review have not changed. Does this status indicate that the reviewers are reviewing the manuscript? There is no information about the reviewers on the interface. Could it be that the reviewers have not been found yet? Should I send an email to urge them? I am anxious to graduate and need this paper to be reviewed urgently. I hope experienced friends can help answer this question.

(0) Thank | zyyyyyyyyyyyy

May I ask where did you submit your contributions? When I tried to submit online through the official website, it redirected me to a personal information page with no option to submit contributions.

(0) Thank | Unique_11

It's been three years since I started, I've sent many reminders, but haven't received a single reply. Now I'm switching gears, the creativity is long gone.

(0) Thank | 爱吃煎饼

The review process is too slow, simply because we cannot find reviewers. I'm so frustrated, this journal is too unreliable, everyone should be cautious when submitting to it.

(0) Thank | bbb222

Hello, my item has been sent back for repair. I looked at their system and there is only an upload button inside. I uploaded a compressed file with all the files inside, is that okay? Also, the system is really strange, after uploading, there is no confirmation button, is it just okay to upload? Where can I confirm? I haven't received any email after uploading, I suspect it wasn't uploaded successfully. Can you share your experience? Help me, I am grateful!

(0) Thank | 土博