On the 21th, I submitted an article. It was still in the initial assessment, which meant that the editor was evaluating it. The official website's instructions of this status are as follows: In order to meet this aim, submitted manuscripts undergo initial evaluation by an editor to ensure that they meet essential criteria for publication in the journal.

(1) Thank | 一颗小胡杨

2020-05-08, submission; 2020-05-09, initial assessment; 2020-05-21, with editor; 2020-05-22, in peer review; 2020-05-26, with editor; 2020-05-28, in peer review; 2020-06-04, minor revision; 2020-06-08, revision; 2020-06-09, in peer review; 2020-06-15, accepted. Thank you very much, professor John Mcgrady.

(1) Thank | 潇潇66

2019-11-04 Submission; 2019-11-06 with editor; 2019-11-08 (around) sent for review 2019-11-22 requiring revisions, two reviewer, two minor revisions, the editor proposed two revision comments; 2019-12-02 revised submission; 2019-12-11 acceptance. The editor Jun Chen is very good. It is my first article in Q1 journals during master's degree. Although it is a small one, I am still satisfied. Come on everyone!

(3) Thank | Lj20131209

Very fast. Three reviewers. One accepted the paper, one had two minor questions, and the third had five minor questions. The editor gave two weeks for major revision. Submitted the revised manuscript after five days and it was accepted after another 10 days. This is extremely fast. One month from submission to acceptance. I also reviewed a paper for the journal and I was required to return the review in 14 days. This way, the review can surely be completed in one month.

(0) Thank | hit

Submission for 3 months, during which three major revisions are suggested to be accepted after revision, and accepted after submission for review, approximately a little over three months.

(0) Thank | 秋.

Update on the progress, there were four reviewers, one of them rejected the paper. The editor then gave the opportunity to resubmit after the rejection. After resubmission, new reviewers were assigned and the paper has been accepted. Thank the editor for the opportunity. Hope ICF can return to the first tier of Chinese Academy of Sciences!

(0) Thank | Till-I

Here is a reference for everyone: I submitted my paper on August 21, 2024 (if I remember correctly, it was the 17th day of submission, and it was under initial review by the editor before that). I received feedback on September 27, 2024 (from two reviewers, with two minor revisions suggested, and the editor requested major revisions, giving me 15 days to make the revisions). I made the revisions on October 4, 2024. The paper was accepted on October 29, 2024 (presumably for a second round of review). I hope this information is helpful to everyone. Good luck!

(0) Thank | iii

Manuscript submitted on March 19, 2025.
Received by editorial office on March 20, 2025.
With editor since March 27, 2025.
It has been 14 days with the editor and still not sent for review, too slow, isn't it?

(0) Thank | 卡卡wave

It has been 20 days since the editor received it, and it has not been submitted for review yet.

(0) Thank | 卡卡wave

I'm also drunk to drop to the second district.

(0) Thank | 小男孩0911

I don't know how to describe my feelings, dropping to the second tier and not being in the top.

(0) Thank | sansan

What's the situation now?

(0) Thank | heartmaker

The submission deadline is December 26, 2024, and the status remains unchanged until March 1, 2025, always under review. What's going on? Should I follow up on it?

(0) Thank | @天天向上

I have submitted my manuscript for two months, and it has been in review for one and a half months without any feedback. What's going on? Isn't the journal's homepage saying it will provide feedback within 27 days?

(0) Thank | @天天向上

It has been two months and the paper is still in peer review... This is the first time I have encountered such slow reviewers.

(0) Thank | Till-I

Please also ask how to check the status of the review.

(0) Thank | Till-I

Just want to ask everyone, what does it mean when the submission status switches between "in peer review" and "with editor"? Also, how can we see how many reviewers are assigned or how many reviewer comments have been received?

(0) Thank | 孤独的 PhD

Hello, did you have a second review after submitting the revised draft?

(0) Thank | iii

Hello, I would like to ask if there was a second review after you submitted the revised manuscript.

(0) Thank | iii

Submitted on 7.15.
Rejected on 7.22 because it does not meet the novelty and impact requirements of the journal.

(0) Thank | 想自由1210

It's been 9 days with the editor, will it ever be sent for review? Can it get any slower? Yes, the Japanese rejected me, they really know how to drag it out.

(0) Thank | aadadsaaa

30-June-2024 Checking submission and files
01-July-2024 Initial assessment
03-July-2024 With Editor

(0) Thank | aadadsaaa

The speed is really slow, with few reviewers. Submitted on May 3rd, only one reviewer provided feedback on June 12th, with the editor making a second round of revisions on June 15th, and still no news as of June 17th

(0) Thank | qiuqiuya

May I ask if you are headed towards the crystal direction or the mini-crystal direction?

(0) Thank | Yanduan Yang

Hello, please submit for review a few days after the repair

(0) Thank | 平凡的世界路遥的追随者