2020.3, submission; 2020.5.2, major revision; 2020.5.14, the revised manuscript was submitted; 2020.6.1, accepted.

(4) Thank | Swaggyr

Journal comments here are relatively few. I heard that the review speed is quite slow. I’m looking forward to someone sharing the submission experience. I have submitted the paper and there is no result yet.

(2) Thank | 北方

Quick, yet pertinent reviews. I am not sure about the quality of the journal since it is a new journal, but the reviewers gave me very productive reviews that helped me to improve my article.

(0) Thank | 1587616

It has been more than a year since the manuscript review. I sent an email to the editorial department, but they ignored it.

(0) Thank | 物喜己悲

What a loss, just as I received it, it dropped to Zone 3.

(0) Thank | zouzhixiang

Just received, dropped from Zone 2 to Zone 3, blood loss!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(25) Thank | zouzhixiang

If you are in a hurry, I really don't recommend submitting to this journal. However, there are too few journals in the manufacturing field, which is a dilemma.

(0) Thank | zouzhixiang

Too slow, however the impact factor has decreased so much.

(0) Thank | zouzhixiang

I submitted it in June, and until today, October 25th, it is still under review, very slow. The speed for their own people (Koreans) is generally fast, as it can be accepted within two months.

(2) Thank | zouzhixiang

Slow speed, be cautious before investing. The first trial takes 2 months to yield results: major revisions. After one month of review, the second trial becomes "Reviewers Assigned" and remains in this state for over a month without any change. It has been a four-month process and the outcome is uncertain, causing anxiety as there seems to be no hope for the application.

(1) Thank | Hegh

Very slow, very slow, and the impact factor has also decreased.

(0) Thank | zouzhixiang

I feel that Korean journals are not very friendly to our people. There are too many articles written by Koreans, and the quality does not seem to be that high.

(0) Thank | Dynamo Pooh

Please let me know when the major repairs are completed. It's really frustrating that it doesn't meet the scope of the journal submission. It's a waste of one year.

(0) Thank | Dynamo Pooh

The final date was written incorrectly. The hiring date is 2021-12-13.

(0) Thank | vickie21

After going through three rounds of review, my submission was finally accepted a year and a half after the initial submission. Personally, I feel that the review process was quite fast and the reviewers' comments were very fair. However, the editorial handling was extremely slow. If there is no rush, it is worth trying to submit because the section is not low-ranking.

Below is the timeline for reference:
New Submission: 2020-07-09
Under Review: 2020-10-20
Under Review: 2021-04-12
Reviews completed: 2021-05-04
Major revision: 2021-06-04

Revision submitted: 2021-06-30
Under Review: 2021-07-12
Minor revision: 2021-09-18

Revision submitted: 2021-09-23
Under Review: 2021-11-09
Accept: 2021-12-23

(110) Thank | vickie21

Hello, may I ask what is the status of your manuscript now? Is it still being assigned to an editor?

(0) Thank | Dynamo Pooh

Extremely slow, Editor assigned takes almost two months to allocate, if in a hurry, please consider submitting cautiously, additional payment required for exceeding specified page limit.

(10) Thank | Dr.奶爸

June 3rd, accept but need final revision
June 5th, return of the revised version
June 27th, accept

I thought the minor revision would be accepted quickly, but ended up waiting for nearly half a year. According to the journal's website, the average time for the first decision is 2 months, but the final decision took 5 months. It seems that the review process does indeed align with the announcement. The journal has experienced a rapid increase in impact in recent years, but it also seems that the self-citation rate has also increased significantly.

(0) Thank | 发条匠

2020.11.05 Submission
2021.01.17 Major revision
2021.03.09 Revised manuscript returned
2021.04.20 Editor Assigned for 20 days
2021.05.09 After sending a reminder, received a response stating, "As far as I know your paper has been accepted." However, the status has not changed. Has anyone had a similar experience?

(0) Thank | 墨偌3A87

Posted on January 14th
Edited and replied to minor revisions on March 30th
Minor revisions resubmitted on April 4th
Currently waiting.

(0) Thank | 发条匠

2.9 Submission 3.2 Feedback received Minor revisions 3.16 Resubmitting minor revisions 3.31 Under review, waiting

(0) Thank | 奶茶爱喝不喝

In the early stage, I usually wait for about a month before reminding. For the subsequent revisions, there was a 20-day interval in between. You can search for the revision letter online!

(0) Thank | 祎祎

Senior, how long have you been sending reminder letters? And how should we write a reminder letter? The assigned reviewers haven't made any progress for over a month. Please advise!

(0) Thank | 相信未来666

Submitted on 2020.10.8, reviewers assigned on 11.16 and 12.26, under review on 12.27, major revision requested on 2021.1.6, revision submitted on 1.21, editor assigned on 1.22, editor assigned on 1.25, editor assigned on 2.2, under review on 2.16, editor assigned on 2.24, accepted on 3.2. There were several reminders in between, but the editor was still very good and the speed was acceptable, considering the journal's submission cycle is over 200 days. Hoping the journal continues to improve!

(12) Thank | 祎祎