Journal of Integrative Agriculture

Sorry, I can't help but come here to complain about this journal. The review is really too slow. It took 3 months for the first review. I can’t wait to call the managing editor. The managing editor said that the review is over, but they must show it to the editor-in-chief. At that time, the system status was Awaiting reviewer. I don’t know if it’s wrongly spelt. Then the managing editor told me that the Section Editor-in-Chief hadn’t review it yet, and I may need to wait because he was very busy. After less than a second, the managing editor said, “Forget it. I’ll send you the comments. You can make the revisions first”. And then I started revising immediately. By the way, they let me make a major revision. After revising for less than 20 days, I quickly submitted it. Then I start waiting for the second review. It was sent to one of the reviewers of the first review. I waited and waited… After more than three months, it hadn't got reviewed yet. I just wanted to say, come on, will you hurry up? Now it can be considered as the end of the review, and it had been handling by the Section Editor-in-Chief. It has been held there for almost two weeks but no news yet. The impact factor of this journal is only less than 1. How can it be that a year was needed for reviewing the manuscript? I would not be surprised if it was closed. I just wish this rubbish journal be closed down soon, and I will never submit to it again. Suggest everyone not to submit.

(21) Thank | zyl

Submitted in mid-May, got the decision of major revision after a little more than a month. The second round of review was done by a different reviewer for rereview, and the comments were much fewer than the first round. Then I was asked to do minor revisions. Accepted in early November, and officially published in April the next year. Some delay during the revision stage was due to my own reasons, and the status of editor final decision lasted for more than a month. This is the first time I submit to an SCI journal. I feel as long as the topic fits the scope of the journal, it’s not so difficult. The big drawback is that this journal recommends a language editing company. I think their editing wasn’t that good, so after I got their edited paper back, I had to selectively accept their changes.

(2) Thank | 小李

Submitted, 1 month, how is it still awaiting reviewer selection?What happened?Say good replies in the February review?

(0) Thank | niejunjun521@126.com

The review speed is OK, but the review draft needs to pay 300 yuan for the review fee.I am now rejected and do not know how to reimburse...The editor found two reviewers. The two opinions are not very good, but the questions are more practical and relevant.

(0) Thank | 月布雷先生

Overhaul once, minor repairs twice, and finally the language check has not been.Later, I made a language change and selectd for more than a month. Is it awaiting reviewer selection, will not be tragedy?Some great gods exchange experience...

(1) Thank | 1739885233@qq.com

After 3 weeks of online submission, I received an editorial letter saying that the article model is more inappropriate for the journal, so it is no longer sent to the reviewer and directly rejected.

(0) Thank | 牛大姐

submitted four reviewers in the first instance, which was rejected and lacked in innovation. The journal asked to put the method at the end, but there are reviewers who should put it in front, so noKnow what is going on.

(0) Thank | 啊啊啊

Submitted to the official typography for nearly one and a half years before the publication of the

(0) Thank | lichunhong88928@163.com

The journal is very self-willed and very proud. The first and second trials use different reviewers, which is rather lacking.The first two people were very quick, and the news was more than a month. They were all minor repairs.After the repair, he returned to the second instance, and he was rejected for more than one month. He was more than three months before and after.With such a harsh review rule, I feel that the journal has great ambitions. Although the starting point is very low, it is likely to become a top journal in agriculture in a few years.

(7) Thank | 哈了个哈

how so deserted, is it not a sci journal?Is this journal an English version of Chinese agricultural science?I selectd for one, and I still don't know the result until now.

(2) Thank | 海博