It took a total of 5 months from submission to acceptance. One major revision and one minor revision was required during this period. It was published online one month after the acceptance. There were two reviewers, one suggested a minor revision during the first review, one recommended a major revision, and finally a major revision was required. The reviewers read very carefully and you can submit articles with certain innovative initial results. 2020.05.15 submitted to the journal; 2020.09.04 major revision; 2020.09.23 revision submitted to journal; 2020.10.03 minor revision; 2020.10.26 revision submitted to journal; 2020.10.27 accepted; 2020.11.26 available online.

(8) Thank | L^_^

It took 3 months from submission to acceptance. The overall speed was fast, and the comments of the reviewers were very professional, which greatly improved the article. I wish the journal better and better! The following are the specific timelines of the status of the article: 2020.7.09, Submit to journal; 2020.7.10, awaiting editor assignment; 2020.7.20, peer review in progress; 2020.8.12, awaiting reviewer scores; 2020.8.22, awaiting recommendation; 2020.9.03, awaiting decision; 2020.9.09, minor revision; 2020.9.10, revision has been submitted; peer review in progress; 2020.9.28, awaiting decision; 2020.9.30, accept.

(18) Thank | alikewang

A revision has been submitted. 10-Oct-2019 manuscript submitted; Major Revision (18-Dec-2019); 12-Jan-2020 revision version submitted; Minor Revision (30-Jan-2020); 30-Jan-2020 revision manuscript submitted; Accept (11-Feb-2020). In general, it is very quick. Thanks to the Editor Treneman, S., hope the journal gets better and better!

(19) Thank | taiyanghefeng

I have reviewed articles for this journal. Only a few were submissions by Chinese authors who clearly needed help with the English language. I recommend ESL authors get some kind of writing assistance before submitting their articles. The review period of this journal is very fast, giving the reviewers 20 days of review time.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Overhaul: one is fourteen pieces, one is fifteen pieces.

(0) Thank | gzzzzz

25.01.20 Awaiting Admin Processing
2025.2.10 Awaiting Editor Assignment
2025.04.21 Peer review in process
2025.06.22 Major Revision
2025.07.13 Awaiting Admin Processing
2025.07.16 Peer review in process
2025.07.21 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2025.07.28 Awaiting Recommendation
2025.08.05 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2025.08.06 Awaiting Decision
2025.08.07 Accepted

(0) Thank | gzzzzz

Thank you for providing the submission link, it has been accepted after major revisions, but I am unable to send private messages.

(0) Thank | XATU东东

Please translate the following paragraph into English: None

(0) Thank | XATU东东

Finding reviewers in the early stage and waiting for their feedback was slow, but the handling of revisions by the editor was fast. Two reviewers: Reviewer 1 raised 9 questions, while Reviewer 2 seemed to have not understood much and only wrote a brief paragraph, giving the impression of a rejection. However, the editor ultimately requested major revisions, which led to the manuscript being accepted after the revisions. The editor was efficient.

25.2.19 Manuscript submission
25.2.26 Resubmission after formatting changes
25.2.27 Assignment of Associate Editor (awaiting assignment)
25.3.5 Peer review in process
25.4.22 Awaiting review scores
25.5.25 Awaiting recommendations
25.5.26 Awaiting decision
25.5.27 Major revision
25.6.23 Revisions made
25.6.27 Peer review in process
25.7.2 Awaiting review scores
25.7.19 Awaiting recommendations
25.7.21 Acceptance

(1) Thank | XATU东东

Ah!!! Two years!!!

(0) Thank | fzzzlucy

It's too slow, it took two years for the review, and three months after acceptance, there is still no proof. Oh my god!!!!!!!!!!

(0) Thank | stephenkk

Is this situation normal, guys?

(0) Thank | halloly

How is the older brother doing now?

(0) Thank | fzzzlucy

You just wait for this journal.

(0) Thank | zyy真厉害

It has been 1 week since submission, and it is still in the "Awaiting Admin Processing: Your manuscript has been received and is undergoing initial formatting checks." status. Is this normal, comrades?

(0) Thank | halloly

Submission: 24-Jun-2024
Major revision: 09-Jan-2025
Resubmission: 06-Mar-2025
Minor revision: 17-Mar-2025
Resubmission: 23-Mar-2025
Acceptance: 10-Apr-2025

(0) Thank | YuXingxing

About three months.

(0) Thank | 肥工螺丝工

Hello, I have a submission stuck at the second step and it won't proceed further. It prompts me that there is an unpublished article. What should I do about this? Are there any specific submission requirements?

(1) Thank | 沉默不是金

Hello, I am in the same situation, unable to proceed to the next step. Have you solved it?

(0) Thank | 沉默不是金

Hello, I have a problem with submitting my manuscript at the second step. It says there are some missing files that need to be uploaded. What should I do? Are there any specific submission requirements?

(0) Thank | 沉默不是金

I submitted on April 17th and just found the reviewer yesterday.

(0) Thank | 太-

Submitted on May 5th, 25 years.
Still looking for reviewers on July 17th, 25 years.
Is this too slow? What should I do?

(0) Thank | GG bond

Hello, how long has this state been going on?

(0) Thank | serd34

How long did the first review of the draft take?

(0) Thank | 洪高天

How can I check the progress of the review?

(0) Thank | hatim