The review speed was not fast, and the reviewers’ opinions were very tricky, which were difficult to answer. Finally, it was accepted after revision. The impact factor was too low. Although the quality of this journal is good, I feel a bit at a loss. This year’s impact factor has dropped to 0.8.

(2) Thank | 烨然

The reviewers are a bit tough and the processing speed is a bit slow. There were three experts reviewing the manuscript, and one of the experts' opinions was very layman in terms of the comments. This caused me some concern but overall my experience was okay.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The text translates to: "I submitted to Philosophical Magazine Letters, but in the future, I can submit to Philosophical Magazine."

(0) Thank | 潇洒哥

2021 08 Submission
Under Review shortly after a day or two, this journal has two stages of review: lowercase "Under Review" means the editorial department's own review, and uppercase "Under Review" means peer review.
2021 10 05 Major Revision
Provided three months for revisions.
2021 12 23 Returned with revision
No news in between.
2022 04 Accepted

(1) Thank | 潇洒哥

Does this journal require a publication fee?

(0) Thank | wuzihuan

Editing the reply is faster, the question is very sharp, I have to admire, the grammar requirements are very strict, come and go to modify the language problem three times.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Reviewers' comments are very serious and detailed, and the editors are very enthusiastic.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Very good journal, partial theory, reviewer is super serious!Articles in the material class are definitely not worse than Scripta Materialia, but the impact factor is not as good as Scripta Materialia.

(1) Thank | Anonymous