Manuscript Received 20-Aug-2020; Awaiting Referee Reports 24-Aug-2020; Awaiting Decision 11-Oct-2020; Moderate Revision 12-Oct-2020; Manuscript Received 24-Oct-2020. The manuscript was resubmitted as we forgot to upload the editable manuscript and source files; Manuscript Received 29-Oct-2020; Awaiting Referee Reports (Copyright signed) 02-Nov-2020; Provisionally Accepted 10-Nov-2020; Formal Accept 13-Nov-2020. Two reviewers, about 30 comments; a moderate revision was required in the first review, and it was accepted directly after revision. The speed is very fast and the opinions are very professional. The editor also replies emails very timely.

(23) Thank | 好好学习天天向上

2020.8.8 submitted; 2020.10.9 major revision. The two reviewers made a total of six or seven opinions. There were two opinions that were difficult to revise. It was revised according to one of the opinions, and we rejected to revise according to another one of the opinions with euphemistic explanation. 2020.10.20 revision submitted; 2020.11.3 moderate revision. Two reviewers approved the previous revisions, one of them raised a minor question, and the other pointed out some grammatical errors. 2020.11.4 revision submitted 2020.11.10 Accepted Overall it took three months from submission to acceptance. As everyone said before, the editor of the journal is very responsible, and the manuscript processing speed is very fast. If your it is innovative and the work is abundant, there should be no problem.

(5) Thank | sanctitude

The manuscript was submitted at the end of November; copyright completion submitted at the beginning of December. Moderate revision was required at the beginning of February, and it took 12 days for the revision. Minor revision was required at the end of February, and it took 3 days for the revision. It was provisionally accepted at the beginning of March. A days later, it was formally accepted. This journal has relatively high requirements for English, and the language should be revised carefully. The reviewers I met were quite good, and the questions raised were not too many. The editor was serious and responsible and sent many reminder emails during the period.

(1) Thank | 打工仔

My general feeling is that the journal editor's editing process is very efficient. The reviewers are very professional, and the articles are more innovative and high quality than in other journals.

(3) Thank | 312774006@qq.com

Hey, what's your current status? I've also "decided" for a few days now.

(0) Thank | 球球了中一篇吧

The journal will be sent to the email of the corresponding author or the first author. In the email, there will be a link, clicking on the link, it seems that there is no author center for submitting articles.

(0) Thank | 球球了中一篇吧

It has been three weeks since the return for rework and there is still no progress. I think we will get the results back in another two weeks. I am anxiously waiting.

(0) Thank | Yi Zhao

The first trial has been awaiting a decision for a week, and there has been no response from the editor. What should we do?

(0) Thank | 就叫这个

Boss, where do I fill in the copyright information? I looked around but couldn't find it.

(0) Thank | pu

Boss, where do I fill in the copyright form? I couldn't find it in the email from the Author Center.

(0) Thank | pu

Does anyone know where to fill out the copyright form? I didn't receive any email in the author center.

(0) Thank | pu

May I ask what is the content of the email link sent to the corresponding author? I am not the corresponding author, my supervisor is. I don't always ask my supervisor, so I would like to check the content of the link and ask my teacher later.

(0) Thank | will

Which stage is it to send an email to the corresponding author?

(0) Thank | 清风明月照我心

Record the long review process, with a small incident in the middle leading to the whole process taking more than 9 months.

2024.10.27 Submission
2024.12.09 Major revision
2024.12.19 Revised
2025.01.29 Provided proof of adding authors
After this, due to the need to change the teacher to the corresponding author, I was unable to receive further inquiries from the journal. My supervisor didn't check the email and didn't tell me that I needed to submit information. So after waiting for a long time and not receiving any updates on the submission status, the document was archived. It wasn't until I proactively contacted the journal on 2025.04.02 that I found out. The editor was very kind and allowed me to resubmit, asking me to attach the previous review responses and said they would try to send it to the original reviewers.

2025.04.02 Resubmission
2025.07.08 Minor revision - One reviewer accepted, while two reviewers had comments
2025.08.01 Provisionally accepted

(0) Thank | 别拒我了球球编辑

After submitting the rework, an email link will be sent to me for completion, and some information will only be sent to the corresponding author's email.

(0) Thank | DASDE

When should the copyright be filled out?

(0) Thank | supercen

Record the submission
Submitted on 5.15
Under review on 5.28
Major revisions on 6.20 (8+4 revision suggestions)
Resubmitted after revisions on 7.12
Pre-accepted on 7.23
Officially accepted on 7.29
Formatting on 7.30
The overall process was quite fast.

(1) Thank | DASDE

Just one week in general.

(0) Thank | 我想发SCI

At the beginning, I would like to express my gratitude to the editors, the journal, and the reviewers for their valuable comments and suggestions on my paper.

(0) Thank | accept1111111

I submitted to 21, but it has not been sent for external review yet.

(0) Thank | Cs....

The pre-acceptance was sent on the evening of the 11th, but it has been stuck on this interface. How long does it usually take for the pre-acceptance to be accepted, and will any emails be sent during this period?

(1) Thank | healer151

The second reviewer agreed to review on July 27th.

(0) Thank | ChenKC_bupt

Check out the official account.

(0) Thank | sduaissd

I submitted on the 17th, why is it still showing as "manuscript received"? Are they on summer break over there?

(1) Thank | GHZHOU

Submission on June 7, 2025
Review on June 18, 2025
Is it necessary to urge the review process as it has not been completed yet? My classmate's submission to this journal was reviewed and completed within twenty days.

(0) Thank | lllllxxxx