After 70 days of review, the manuscript was rejected. The three reviewers gave very detailed and professional review comments, and each question raised was on the point. The editor suggested that it to be changed to another journal after careful revision, which proved that my paper was denied. This journal is one of the top journals in the field of information systems, and unless the author is very authoritative or the content of the manuscript is worthy of attention, it is difficult to publish in here.

(20) Thank | Lyon

The journal attaches great importance to practicality and has high requirements for data quality and the assumptions of empirical research.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

March 27th Re投
May 7th Major

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

It has been a week since submission, and it is still "Under Review." Has it not been sent for approval yet?

(0) Thank | JGOGOGO6

The journal is a good journal.

(0) Thank | 老三

Two major revisions, one minor revision. During the minor revision, the editor-in-chief changed. Initially agreed to accept the paper after the minor revision, but after the change of editor-in-chief, the paper was rejected as having no value. This process lasted for a year. Everyone should be cautious about submitting to this journal. It was the first time encountering such a situation, leaving a psychological shadow that took several months to recover from. After all, the team worked hard on three revisions, all of which were accepted after the minor revision.

(0) Thank | 科研的猫

2025.02.04 reject and resubmit after very major

All three reviewers are very interested, one minor revision, two major revisions, AE suggests very major.

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

First of all, this journal is a well-established three-star, and it is also recognized by IEEE T, and the engineering field. We submitted an article two years ago, and after 12 months, it was accepted with three revisions from seven reviewers. Personally, I feel it leans towards business management, which they made clear in their feedback.

(1) Thank | bajidou

In normal circumstances, this journal undergoing review is simply under review.

(0) Thank | ALovelyDolphin

It has been over two months, and the situation has not changed.

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

I was in UR status right after I submitted my article, the whole process was like a black box to me and I couldn't see the specific workflow, I also didn't know how long it would take for the editors to review it.

(0) Thank | KSS

It has been over a month since I submitted my article, but it is still stuck in "Undergoing Review" status. What's going on?

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

Can AI review papers? It's unbelievable! After 11 months, they actually had AI review the paper, so irresponsible. Be cautious when submitting to these small circle journals, they have already been ruined!!!

(0) Thank | mmwxx

What is the status after undergoing review? Does it mean the manuscript was rejected based on the reviewers' comments?

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

The submission was under review on the day of submission, and then it took over four months. Finally, the editor-in-chief sent an email saying that they couldn't find a reviewer during these four months, and the paper was rejected. I am truly grateful.

(1) Thank | jst874406515

Submitted for review on May 13th of the same day
Received rejection feedback on November 9th
Reason: leaning towards technical rather than managerial aspects. Lao Deng insisted on a square peg in a round hole, leaving me no way out!

(0) Thank | KSS

It has been a week since submitted, but the editors have not assigned it yet and have not made any progress.

(0) Thank | 只想被科研搞

Not only undergoing review is external audit, I emailed the editor and the editor's response was to wait for the reviewer's comments.

(0) Thank | Vi1zzZ

It has been undergoing review for 10 months and I don't know when it will end. Sending emails to the editor only results in polite replies.

(0) Thank | Vi1zzZ

The review comments have come back after about two and a half months. May I ask what the current status is now?

(0) Thank | 清纯男高

The submission on August 13th is under going review, and on October 29th it is awaiting Editor-in-Chief Decision. Can I ask if the external review has been received?

(0) Thank | 要加油！

Hello, have you sent an email to DE? It has been three months for me, I am a little anxious... afraid of not being able to graduate...

(0) Thank | 清纯男高

It is better to choose some mainstream journals with fast review speeds. Even if rejected, at least it won't waste much time. It has been 8 months since submission, if it were to be rejected now, it would be really frustrating!

(0) Thank | mmwxx

I have sent an email and asked, but still no reply. It's ridiculous, the cost performance is not high, I do not recommend investing!!!

(0) Thank | mmwxx

Have you sent an email to DE to inquire about the situation?

(0) Thank | 清纯男高