2019.12.21, submission; 2020.2.14, the result was returned. There were 4 reviewers, three of them required minor revision, and one reviewer accepted it directly. Each reviewer raised 7 or 8 minor review questions, which were relatively professional. The editor also raised 10 questions. A very professional editor. The questions on infrared were raised. Language issues were also pointed out and it is recommended to polish. I revised and answered all of the questions with patience. Especially, the requirements on questions of the pictures were relatively strict; 2020.3.18, the revision was submitted. However, the editor didn’t think it was revised well. I didn’t understand a question at that time, and the editor returned it directly and asked me to continue to revise, and gave me one month for revision). I was careful to figure out all the questions and revised it again; 2010 4.15, sent for external review; 2020.4.27, both of the reviewers thought it can be accepted. The editor raised some questions about the English tense and told me the specific revision methods. It was revised in 5 minutes. However, because of the delay, it was submitted relatively late. 2020.5.21, submitted, the status didn’t change; 2020.6.4, accepted directly. Overall, it was relatively smooth. However, the editor is very strict, and the article can only be accepted after all the problems of the article were revised. The submitted article needs to be innovative, otherwise it will not be reviewed. It took more than 6 months in total! (Look at the email you used for reply, I know that you are Dong Lin.)

(25) Thank | 木子李1234

Is there anyone whose article recently got accepted can share the schedule and other information? Good luck, everyone. guoliangyan@nefu.edu.cn

(0) Thank | Liangyan Guo

Strong journal, but very demanding. Strict on submission details. The reviewer was very professional.

(0) Thank | munu

Submitted in June, returned for major revisions in August, after two rounds of minor revisions following the major revisions, accepted in mid-October.

(0) Thank | 云飘

Posted on December 9th, 2020: underview
Returned for major revision on February 10th, 2021, given 2 months. There were many questions asked and strict requirements for the figures.
Returned for minor revision on March 12th, 2021, and returned on March 26th, the same day, for format and figure issues.
Accepted on April 10th, 2021.
Overall, it went relatively smoothly, but no minor issues were overlooked. You need to make modifications.

(1) Thank | Dylan

has been submitteding for a month and a half, waiting.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

http://www.reference-global.com/loi/hfsgThis is the journal homepage

(1) Thank | Anonymous