10 Jun 2025 (06:12:24) Article accepted for publication.
08 Jun 2025 (02:05:49) Review of Reviewer 4 finalized.
04 Jun 2025 (06:42:23) Associate Editor posted new comments.
24 May 2025 (10:10:01) Review of Reviewer 3 finalized.
(00:10:04) Review of Reviewer 1 finalized.
17 Mar 2025 (02:44:40) Corresponding Author submitted manuscript.

(0) Thank | ouer

The first deputy editor ran away, feeling that the journal was responsible, arranged for the second deputy editor, and also thanked the second deputy editor.

(0) Thank | ouer

May I ask what happened later? It has been almost 2 months since I received my Editorial Assignment, but there has been no progress. I am worried that my paper will be rejected because I cannot find a reviewer. Another paper of mine was withdrawn in the same way. (/ㄒoㄒ)/~~

(0) Thank | gkgkgkgkg

Will there be email notifications for each step? Will the first author receive notifications?

(0) Thank | gkgkgkgkg

Roughly around the same time you received all the submissions, I am still on editorial assignment. You are so fast, I envy you.......

(0) Thank | gkgkgkgkg

4.11 Initial Validation, Editorial Assignment
4.23 Independent Review
5.5 Reviewer1 completed
5.9 Reminded the reviewer in the morning, Reviewer2 completed in the afternoon but only Reviewer2 uploaded to the system
5.9 Received revision notice in the evening, one Major and one Minor (considered for publication), given ten days, major revisions with five questions, quite a lot of experimental data
5.15 re-submit
5.16 review finalized
5.19 Back to Interactive Review, open the comments of Reviewer2 who agreed to publish, and let us reply
5.20 Review Finalized
5.21 Back to the fourth step Interactive Review
5.24 Reviewer1 agrees to publish
5.26 Reviewer2 agrees to publish, Review Finalized
5.26 Sixth step Final Validation
5.26 Accepted in the evening
Overall, it was quite fast, less than two months, mainly being able to find reviewers to review for you, the rule is that reviewers must return their comments within 10 days.

(0) Thank | 落坨翔子

What should I do if there is no response after proofreading?

(0) Thank | 6顺

Submission of manuscript on 8/15/2024
Major revision submission on 10/12/2024
Minor revision submission on 10/27/2024
Review completed on 10/30/2024
Accepted on 11/5/2024
Proofreading on 11/13/2024
To be continued...

(0) Thank | 刺猬PiPi

It's really slow, it's been three months already. Can I send an email to ask? Did the editor forget?

(0) Thank | 6顺

I would like to ask, how long does the Editorial Assignment phase take? It has been almost a month and I am still in the stage of inviting editors and reviewers.

(0) Thank | zjlnydky

How are you doing now?

(0) Thank | zjlnydky

Could you please let me know how long it takes for the article to be indexed in the Web of Science after acceptance in July?

(0) Thank | 蔚蓝

Hello, may I ask if the editor has not handled it yet? Can we send an email to inquire?

(0) Thank | Tanyuping

Wish the journal better and better

(0) Thank | 小伙D

Overall it's okay, but the first round of reviewers returned their comments relatively slowly, which may be related to the fact that the direction is not very mainstream

(0) Thank | 小伙D

20 Sep 2023, Accepted after revision
19 Sep 2023, Editorial revision feedback, minor edits
18 Sep 2023, Reviewer 2 completed review, accepted
18 Sep 2023, Revised as per Reviewer 2's comments
17 Sep 2023, Reviewer 3 completed review, accepted
16 Sep 2023, Reviewer 2 feedback, minor edits
07 Sep 2023, Submitted revised manuscript
03 Sep 2023, Reviewer 3 feedback, major revisions
29 Aug 2023, Interactive review forum opens automatically
24 Aug 2023, Reviewer 2 feedback, major revisions
03 Jul 2023, Reviewer 1 completed review, accepted
22 Mar 2023, Resubmitted
16 Mar 2023, Requested resubmission
15 Mar 2023, Submission

(0) Thank | 小伙D

The overall experience was okay, but one of the reviewers took a long time to review the manuscript

(0) Thank | 小至

Check it out on the official website

(0) Thank | w222

"1 time, 3 experts."

(0) Thank | 王八蛋666

Excuse me, how many times have you made modifications in total? How many experts?

(0) Thank | 小伙D

Submitted to acceptance, approximately 34 days. Additionally, the cost has increased to $2080.

(1) Thank | 王八蛋666

The price has increased. Previously, the cost for research articles was $950, but now it has been changed to $2080.

(0) Thank | SummerDream

How is the article charged? I have written a comprehensive one. Looking forward to your answer.

(13) Thank | inf

Very fast, from submission to acceptance, exactly 20 days. Hoping to be in the second zone, haha.
12 Aug 2022 Typesetting initiated.
                     Article accepted for publication.
11 Aug 2022 Review of Review Editor 1 finalized.
                     Corresponding Author re-submitted manuscript.
                     You posted new comments.
08 Aug 2022 Interactive review forum activated.
23 Jul 2022 Corresponding Author submitted manuscript.

(4) Thank | w222

This magazine is quite fast, it takes one and a half months for acceptance and one month for online publication. The quality of the articles is also acceptable, probably classified as a second-tier publication by the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

(4) Thank | China no1