Submitted to journal, 2020.03.24; With editor, 2020.03.24; Under review, 2020.03.26; Major revision, 2020.04.24; With editor, 2020.04.26; Reviewer invited, 2020.04.26; Under review, 2020.05.02; Ready for decision, 2020.06.01; Decision pending, 2020.06.05; Accept, 2020.06.06. The above are the timelines of the review process recorded in detail, for your information. It can be seen that the review time of the reviewers was basically finished in a month after under review; The comments of the reviewers were returned after major revision. Two of the reviewers required minor revision, one reviewer only have a word that the organization of the article was in a mess, which was opposite to the conclusion of the second reviewer: the organization of the article was good. It was estimated that this reviewer didn’t review it carefully. Ready for Decision and Decision Pending are respectively mean that the article is with associate editor and with editor-in-chief. The efficiency is high compared to other journals.

(4) Thank | 启航

After submission, it was staying in the editor's hands for a week to find reviewers. Each time comments came back, the editor basically responded within 1 week. The submission cycle is mainly depending on the reviewer; the speed is okay. During the period, the reviewer delayed it for more than a month after one revision and I sent an email to urge. Three days later, the reviewer comments returned and it was accepted directly.

(1) Thank | qwer123456

54 days to acceptance. Quite fast. Although it was an invited topic.

(15) Thank | liusj2017@gmail.com

Is there any movement or noise?

(0) Thank | 当一次天花板你

For nearly three months, only one person has been reviewing the manuscript.

(0) Thank | 当一次天花板你

How do you see yourself as the editor-in-chief?

(0) Thank | 不吃糖的小硕士

Submitted in April, so far only one reviewer has been invited. After the review was completed, now going directly to the decision process...

(0) Thank | accepter、、

Hello, I submitted my paper on energy and buildings in early May, and it has been under review for a month without any results. Is this a normal speed?

(0) Thank | dou

March 22, 2025 Submit
March 25, 2025 Under Review
April 19, 2025 RRC 2
April 28, 2025 RRC 3
April 28, 2025 RC
April 29, 2025 Major Revision
May 15, 2025 Re-Submit
May 16, 2025 UR
May 26, 2025 RC 0→1
May 28, 2025 RC 1→2 RRC
May 30, 2025 Accept

(0) Thank | June

I have also been in WE for 15 days, and the date has changed once.

(0) Thank | Terry Chung

I submitted the manuscript half a month ago and it is still in the "WE" status. It feels like the review process is seriously out of line with what I have seen before. Should I send an inquiry about the manuscript?

(0) Thank | Terry Chung

Just want to ask everyone, when submitting the initial draft, do we have to strictly limit the number of pages to be within 20 pages?

(0) Thank | 廷

Yes, I have been working for 10 days and still on WE, the date has changed once.

(0) Thank | KEEEV

It has been 13 days since I submitted my article, but it still hasn't been assigned to an editor. Is ENB really this slow now?

(0) Thank | 潇洒_

Share a submission experience: If there are issues with generating a PDF format when submitting paper materials, simply convert the file to .doc format.

(0) Thank | 草文

The first ENB paper, focusing on thermal comfort, was assigned to Cao Bin for editing. Teacher Cao was very responsible, and the comments from the reviewers were very professional. The two rounds of revisions lasted for 4 months and were accepted on February 21st.

(0) Thank | 草文

May I ask how the current results are? Can the direction of power system optimization scheduling be submitted to this journal related to energy sources? Thank you! I hope to be hired soon.

(0) Thank | 柠檬酸奶呦

Send 5 and receive 1, 1 is completed. It is currently in minor review on the system. The email has not been sent yet. Do we still need to wait for other reviewers?

(0) Thank | jrlbj

Three people agreed to review the document, but in the end, only two of them provided feedback.

(0) Thank | bazingaa

The HVAC system.

(0) Thank | bazingaa

The results were given on the same day, pretty fast!

(0) Thank | 呆呆阿超

Jun 28, 2024 With editor
Jun 30, 2024 Under review
Dec 20, 2024 Major revision
Mon 15, 2025 Under review
Mar 18, 2025 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 19, 2025 Accept

I submitted a review article, the editor was very efficient, but during the second review, one of the reviewers did not accept the review invitation, which delayed the process. Fortunately, they eventually accepted it, taking about 9 months in total.

(0) Thank | nosweetie

Mar 18, 2025 with editor

(0) Thank | 呆呆阿超

March 10, 2025 Decision in Process

(0) Thank | 丁一一

Jan 07, 2025 Submitted
Mar 09, 2025 Required Reviews Completed
This is considered fast in terms of the reviews I have encountered.

(0) Thank | 丁一一