It has been submitted for almost a year, and has always been external review. What's going on? I sent two reminders, and the first time I was replied that it usually took about 12 months. I don't know what to do at the moment?

(7) Thank | Zengwen

The article was submitted in December 2019, the comments of revision was sent back in February, and major revision was required. It was resubmitted on March 3, and revision was required in the returned comments. It was accepted in half a month. It was too troublesome.

(6) Thank | chrqrq

This journal falls into the review category. I recommend contacting the editor if you’re unsure if your manuscript is appropriate for publication in this journal – they have a lot of review issues that non-review papers can contribute towards. Overall, the quality of the articles is high. The impact factor has been above 5 in recent years. However, relatively speaking, the articles are narrowly focused and less timely since they are all reviews.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

Hello, may I ask if this journal will continue to "we" until reviewers are found? I have been waiting for over a month and sent an email inquiring about the status of inviting reviewers, but I am unsure if it is true or not.

(0) Thank | "zzz"

Hello, may I ask how long does it take from the submission to the external review? It has been almost two months since I submitted.

(0) Thank | "zzz"

Hello, may I ask how long have you been with the editor? It has been almost a month and I want to follow up.

(0) Thank | "zzz"

There is a high probability of being rejected.

(0) Thank | Jack Lee

After I applied, I got a direct rejection letter within 3 days. Does this mean I was rejected?

(0) Thank | 无与

I directly DP after WE, does it mean I was rejected?

(1) Thank | 无与

After submitting the manuscript, it had been four or five months with the editor. I wrote a follow-up letter urging them to expedite the review process, and soon after, it was sent for review. After revisions, the manuscript was accepted for publication.

(0) Thank | Jack Lee

Received, happy, the editing process was still very fast. However, it took a relatively long time with the reviewer during the second review. After the reviewer completed the review, it was recorded in less than a week. Overall, it is still acceptable. Thanks to the editor and the reviewer. Excellent!

(0) Thank | 风的速度

I submitted my paper before, and one month after the initial review, it was still pending decision. This status remained for over two months before finally receiving major revisions. It is possible that one reviewer completed their review while others did not.

(0) Thank | 请请请请请

I am also pending for a long time, how about you?

(0) Thank | litingting

Has the status changed now?

(0) Thank | 7754

How long does the Decision Pending status typically last? It's been almost a week and the status hasn't changed yet.

(0) Thank | snow1266

What's going on now? It won't be reviewed for a few days?

(0) Thank | Sci收收收

What's going on with everyone? It's been a week and it still hasn't reached the editor's hands. Still in technical review.

(0) Thank | Sci收收收

16 April Submission Created
16 April Submission Incomplete
16 April Manuscript Submitted
16 April With Journal Administrator
25 April With Editor
30 April With Editor
2 May Out for Review
17 Sep Out for Review
18 Sep Decision Pending
19 Sep Revision Required
20 Sep Revision Incomplete
20 Sep Revised Manuscript Submitted
20 Sep With Journal Administrator
03 Oct With Editor
07 Oct Out for Review
14 Oct Decision Pending
28 Oct Decision Pending
30 Oct Accepted

(0) Thank | 咿呀咿呦

I have not heard from them for three months, so I asked what was going on. They said they had invited over a dozen reviewers, but none of them agreed to review the manuscript. They asked me to recommend some reviewers myself.

(0) Thank | Tina

When I encounter a reviewer who doesn't understand and makes blind comments, I appeal.

(0) Thank | Tina

On August 7th, it was with editor, and it is still with editor until today (August 11th). Are you also experiencing the same situation as me?

(0) Thank | Jack Lee

How come it was rejected in the middle?

(0) Thank | 青橙丶

It's normal, mine has also been around 20 days.

(0) Thank | 青橙丶

Can you share the timeline? Is it normal to still be with the journal administrator after 20 days of submission?

(0) Thank | 何奇秀

Excuse me, how long has it been with the editor? It has been 20 days and it is still with the journal administrator.

(0) Thank | 何奇秀