It took 10 months for the first review. The revision comments were replied on August 5. It has been more than 50 days, but it is still under review. During the period, the date of under review changed twice. The time taken was really too long. However, the questions of the reviewers were not too many, but they were very sharp, and supplementing experiments were required. After a hard work and supplementing the experiments, there is still no news. I hope it can be accepted.

(10) Thank | 云隐私信任

The review period is about 4 months, three reviewers. Not bad, I guess.

(2) Thank | bit_hwj2016

Submitted on November 1, review opinions returned on November 30; after the major revisions, resubmitted for second review on December 25, and the review opinions returned on January 20; after minor revisions, resubmitted for third review; 20 days later, the final decision for acceptance received on February 20. The review cycle is about 4 months, with three reviewers.

(7) Thank | bit_hwj2016

The reviewers generally approve of the article, but one recommended major revisions while the other suggested minor revisions. The reviewer who recommended major revisions, a very professional colleague, provided many detailed theoretical questions and suggested additional experimental validation. However, the editor only allowed one month for revisions.

(0) Thank | ikechan8370

2025.2.1 Submission
2025.2.6 Under Review
2025.5.31 Review Complete / Major Revision
2025.7.2 Under Review

(0) Thank | ikechan8370

Hello, may I ask what is the article number of your post?

(0) Thank | xiaodwa

Just want to ask if it's possible to submit the first draft of this journal using a single-column format, as I couldn't find a template for double-column submission. Thank you all for your help.

(0) Thank | xiaodwa

I have seen similar articles before, and I submitted a few days ago. I don't know why it was also deemed out of scope. Could it be that there is too much submission volume for them to handle?

(0) Thank | issaccc

To do safety, I have read similar articles before, but I don't know why it is also considered out of scope. Could it be that the number of submissions is too large for them to review?

(0) Thank | issaccc

Received an email on the third day stating that the submission is out of scope.

(0) Thank | issaccc

May 24, 2025 Submit
May 25, 2025 With Editor
May 28, 2025 Under Review

(0) Thank | Letpub12300

May I ask what template is used for submission to this journal? Could you please share it with me? Thank you! Email: 202311143@huat.edu.cn

(0) Thank | 嘿嘿子

Hello, may I ask what template is used for submissions? Could you please share it? Thank you very much. ??

(0) Thank | 嘿嘿子

The reviewers and editors are very efficient, working at a fast pace.

(0) Thank | 啊sir中中

May I ask what template you used for the application? Could you please send me the template? Email: d582040690@163.com. Thank you!

(0) Thank | Cher1she

May I ask what template you used to apply for the job? Can you please send me the template? Email: d582040690@163.com. Thank you!

(0) Thank | Cher1she

The editor is very responsible and takes corresponding actions once the manuscript status is updated.

(0) Thank | Pei

How is the paper going now?

(0) Thank | legend

How long did we continue for later?

(0) Thank | legend

How long did it take for it to be submitted for review later?

(0) Thank | legend

Could you please confirm if there are numbers on the left side of the PDF layout for the submission? Such as line numbers, etc.

(0) Thank | kukikuki

- 2024-01-23 Submitted
- 2024-09-20 Required Reviews Completed
- 2024-12-5 With Editor
- 2024-12-16 Significant Revision
- major revision
- 2025-1-2 With Editor
- 2025-1-15 Under Review
- 2025-1-17 Under Review
- 2025-1-21 Under Review
- 2025-1-30 One Reviewer Completed
- 2025-2-14 Required Reviews Completed
- 2025-2-15 Review completed
- minor revision
- 2025-2-17 With Editor
- 2025-2-26 Accept

(1) Thank | Kherrisan

May I ask if the template used is directly from Elsevier or if this journal has a template available for download?

(0) Thank | Sarahhh

May I ask if the template used is directly from Elsevier, or if this journal has a template available for download?

(0) Thank | Sarahhh

Brother, did you directly use the template from Elsevier, or does this journal have a downloadable template?

(0) Thank | 小菜鸟