150 papers are published annually, the acceptance rate is indeed very low, and it is hard to be accepted. Basically most of the submissions will be rejected. It is very difficult to get one article accepted.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

Researching in the camera, I have the opportunity to submit the manuscript to this journal. After two months of review, the manuscript was rejected. The reviewers were strict and liked splitting hairs. In fact, there is a little insufficiency in every research. The manuscript was rejected, and we hastily revised it and submitted it to OE. 3 weeks later, the comments were received, requiring a minor revision. This journal is really abnormal.

(5) Thank | Anonymous

This journal can be regarded as a top journal in Q2 in the industry. It is an authoritative journal. Manuscripts were reviewed very strictly. From article innovation, English to figures, they are reviewed very detailly. Only more than one hundred articles are published a year, and they are considered boutiques. The only drawback is the membership system.

(9) Thank | Anonymous

Membership journal, the instructors are senior members, so they can submit articles. The journals are highly authoritative in the industry, so the review is very strict. The acceptance rate is only about 30%.

(0) Thank | Ivan

Could you please tell me if my paper is related to the machine tool measurement technology direction, and if it is suitable for this journal? What magazine is OE?

(0) Thank | wyl1115731297

Submitted on January 14th, accepted on April 12th

(0) Thank | Mech0207

"Tsinghua University Important International Conference Directory 2023 Edition" - Department of Mechanical Engineering - Discipline of Mechanical Engineering - Important International Conferences (Top Level, A-Class, B-Class): CIRP GA, IMEC&E (ASME), and TMS are all top-level international conferences. They have high requirements for innovation, low acceptance rates, and high industry recognition

(1) Thank | 当时明月在

How many questions did the reviewers ask?

(1) Thank | sustech0207

This journal only accepts submissions from members. I was fortunate to have a paper accepted this year, submitted on January 15th, and the results were announced on March 8th, which is considered relatively fast. In the first round, it was temporarily accepted directly, and the reviewers' comments were constructive, including a suggestion to add a reference. It feels like this journal emphasizes innovation, and if there is a large amount of related research in the same direction, there is a high probability of rejection.

(0) Thank | wjiames

This year, I was fortunate enough to have a paper accepted. After submitting the manuscript, I received revision comments after a month and a half, with four reviewers raising some minor questions. Three days later, I submitted the revised manuscript, and it was accepted after a week. The whole process took exactly two months, which was very fast. The journal has strict formatting and page limits, making the preparation of the paper quite tedious. If there were no restrictions on the layout, I could have provided more experimental details and in-depth discussions.

(15) Thank | CChai

Looks like only CIRP members can contribute, and it is very strict.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

What do you mean?Does this journal have a 2 year paper?Don't make a mistake?

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Two years, the revised draft selectd for three editionsAnd still amending, let's calculate it after the revision, depressed, the cycle is too long.

(0) Thank | Anonymous