The review cycle is about 40 days. The three reviewers are all top experts in the industry. The requirements for innovation and practical value of the work are very high. 1) After submission, the system shows that Manuscript under consideration, which means that it is being evaluated by the editor; 2) If the latest status becomes Editor decision started, it means it has been sent for review (you can also check whether there is reviewer.zip in the file list, if yes, it means it is sent for review). Of course, it will send an email to the corresponding author when it is sent for review. 3) When the status becomes All reviewers assigned, it means that all reviewers have accepted the review; 4) After the comments returned, the status will change to Manuscript under consideration again, and the article now is being evaluated by the editor at this time. The editor will evaluate whether the reviewer has shown great interest in the article. Therefore, even if all three reviewers required revisions, but do not show great interest, the editor will still reject the manuscript. Finally, I wish everyone publish smoothly~

(83) Thank | loverain0626

Everyone, help me see the what probability of acceptance it is. Thank you so much! Title of the article: Coated zeolite imidazole ester framework, used for efficient oxygen. Research direction: Material chemistry, inorganic chemistry, organometallic chemistry, catalysis, small molecule activation.

(1) Thank | 小王子哈

Our research is on phase change energy storage materials. We submitted the paper on October 26 and it was rejected on November 7.  We decided to switch to CC.

(12) Thank | ctranger@163.com

Submitting to top-tier publications is undoubtedly a personal goal, but I have never submitted anything for review. The current feeling is that submitting to this publication is akin to hitting the jackpot, with the advantage of very fast feedback. However, the downside is that I have never been selected, and I don't know what kind of article would meet the editor's requirements.

(0) Thank | Kamiu

Just as it is said online, relying on the naturally high impact factor of Energy without the strictness of old-fashioned journals, Nature suggests transferring here. After waiting for 3 days without an assigned editor, on the 4th day they directly rejected the submission and suggested transferring to a journal with no impact factor. It's really disgusting, only you are in a hurry for Christmas.

(0) Thank | 中篇NC就躺

09.29 submit
01.15 revise (4 reviewers)

02.05 revision submitted
02.25 revise (2 reviewers have comments)

03.12 revision submitted
03.26 accept (all 4 reviewers ok)

High editing efficiency. Article status updates can be viewed on Research Square

(2) Thank | Glenn

Thank you for providing the research idea, but I couldn't make it work. Thanks for reminding me to change directions and submit a new proposal!

(0) Thank | BENYINQQQ

As expected, the rejection letters were sent on January 24th, and the reasons for rejection were all clichés

(0) Thank | companyYS

It's been 7 days and still no progress, I'm really fed up

(0) Thank | companyYS

14th is under consideration

(0) Thank | companyYS

Keep track of how many days it takes to be rejected, submit on 12/13/2023

(23) Thank | companyYS

Don't worry when you submit your application, if rejected it will be within about 3 days, so feel free to give it a try

(0) Thank | 影子

The editing process of the manuscript was very prompt, and it was rejected just 5 days after submission.

(11) Thank | Jumpdowner

Manuscript Transferred on February 14, 2022, transferred to Nature;
Editor assigned on February 15 and Manuscript under consideration;
Rejected on March 1.

(2) Thank | 未发文章

Great God, what was the final result?

(0) Thank | qwerpoiuyt

Hope that the future will be one!Work hard and work harder!

(0) Thank | leah

real-time IF: 4139/92=44.989, too cattle, I hope that the future can be an article

(0) Thank | 厉害的小强

is the NATURE sub-journal, the future development is worth looking forward to

(0) Thank | 科研猫

This year's new SCI's natural sub-publication, the future development trend is very optimistic

(9) Thank | SCIxinshou